David Singer
David Singer
I think we need to be super-careful about the appearances here. I really hope that voting is rare on the council, but if there is dissent and a vote is...
> We think it might be more effective to formalize that it's the Team that appoints the seat but that the Team is charged with reaching out to the W3C...
agreed, I forgot TAG ratification, and yes, term limits are separately tracked
Trying again. Keeping the term limits here so we can see an integrated text. Do we need to explain who gets to vote in the confirmation ballot, in any more...
@TzviyaSiegman I think that's fine. "Members must be able to participate fully in the council without being required to travel."?
@cwilso you make it a statement of fact, whereas I think it needs to be a requirement on those setting up the operation of a council instance…hence my formulation
This is a short 'leaf' section that doesn't complicate the process, so I am easy, except that I think we should try to keep requirements in the process document, and...
I think if we are to reconsider we will need roughly what Chaals did when we adopted it, plus a bit: 1. propose a specific alternative, and explain why it's...
To be clear, I am not opposed to changing the voting system. I just want to know what would be the proposal, specifically, and why it's better. I'd also suggest...
@michaelchampion That's my understanding. I think that there is also a subtle difference in voter instructions – "Please indicate which of the following candidates you would support/be-ok-with serving on the...