ChrisRosser

Results 42 comments of ChrisRosser

Nice idea. One approach could be to limit the max rotation rate to something pretty low like 100 deg/s when in FOAC mode. This should greatly reduce the chance of...

[Log.zip](https://github.com/betaflight/betaflight/files/15126420/Log.zip) Hi Supafly! Thanks for helping me with this. Here is the log file.

Yes each trace is taken during one acceleration run which takes approximately 2 seconds. Logging is at ~100Hz. RPM and torque are both mechanically measured: RPM using an optical tape,...

Here is a test at Dshot600 ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/41840611/199569629-da4cb9a6-48c7-447a-885d-dabd5c10e9f7.png) And Dshot600 with Low RPM power protect off ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/41840611/199570886-6e834569-c253-4d30-87d5-c83d43733cd7.png) Wiggles still seem to be there.

Sure @cbf123 . Here it is! Does this suggest that something might be going on with commutation? ESC current and torque are not directly proportional. ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/41840611/200110579-2661510a-6caa-48e4-9419-02097e69f516.png)

@sskaug Happy to test. MAMBA F55 128K 4110 I have to mention that a slow throttle ramp is a very different test from an inertial dyno run. Ramping throttle slowly...

Test results: MC Firmware ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/41840611/200312538-eb40ed32-6c8e-494d-a638-b906f28ec089.png) FC Firmware ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/41840611/200312875-3e069b79-d50a-4f42-a985-36a26b1932a5.png) BOTH Firmware ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/41840611/200312635-f02fe2aa-8669-44ab-a92e-73d09045766a.png) AM32 for Comparison ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/41840611/200312750-a832f3dc-d2f4-4d90-bd33-eeecb4041a81.png) Analysis: Disabling BEMF Filter definitely improves Torque with no visible penalty in terms of current...

> Great to hear, thank you for testing. The effect from the bemf filter feature is noticeable but probably not very significant in most systems. And with "byRPM" pwm, it...

> The above plots are more informative than the initial plots you shared, as individual measurement points are now shown. What is it that determines the sample rate in your...

> The low rpm power protection scheme use has a lot of inheritance from older BLH versions, and looking at is it in detail, the quantization steps at high power...