Noam Nelke

I don't understand what we gain from this distinction. As I see it there are only two things a node can know about when an ATX was published: 1. I've...

> Isn't this asymmetry with nonce making it possible to spawn a lot of single-sig accounts using the same pubkey with different nonces, meanwhile with self-spawn it is possible to...

I agree with what @selfdual-brain said. > methodArguments can't be represented as array of bytes. even in your document there is no length prefix for method arguments. so it has...

My original plan was to do (3), this has the advantage of making transactions smaller (no need to encode the arguments length), but the downside is that you must know...

How would this work? I don't understand how a nonce can be consumed on a failed self-spawn - if it failed there's no account that can track the nonce. To...

I don't like this separation of epochs - I think it's mostly confusing. I think that I, as a user, would just want to know what rewards I've already earned...

Only thing I would add to what @avive said is that I think that the `SmesherService` is not detailed enough (in addition to not being implemented), so we may need...

Sorry for the late response... IIUC @dshulyak _only_ implemented self-spawn for genesis. I don't fully agree with this, because I think it would be almost as easy to support both...

LGTM Good job on the structure of this spec! Very readable, keeping the technicalities to the footnotes...

Worth also noting that the node has no knowledge of the wallet's private key. It only knows the public key of the coinbase account, where mining rewards are sent. Only...