Marc Portier comments

Results 11 comments of


                                            Marc Portier

Use Case: Describe a collection of highly related files

Understand the stress, do not like the solution. IMHO the tension to "not repeat yourself" should be resolved by tools that help them create the describing graphs. (e.g we are...

Integrate profile registry

@elichad -- could you reach out with some dates that could work for a direct specific call to cover this collaboration? from there each of us could report back to...

[Feature]: Better reading of RO-Crate metadata files

> I know that there are 2 ways that I can specify the URL in the tool in order to get the best reporting, i.e. > https://raw.githubusercontent.com/arms-mbon/data_release_001/main/ro-crate-metadata.json vs https://github.com/arms-mbon/data_release_001/blob/main/ro-crate-metadata.json >...

[Feature]: Better reading of RO-Crate metadata files

I see the [rocrate context](https://www.researchobject.org/ro-crate/specification/1.2-DRAFT/context.jsonld) has provisioning for both encodingFormat and fileFormat And the spec recommendation is to use encodingFormat to hold the mime types https://www.researchobject.org/ro-crate/specification/1.2-DRAFT/data-entities.html#encoding-file-paths

[Feature]: Improve the reading of EML metadata

@huberrob this starts to sound we could be fixing our eml first? (rather then already a clear feature / improvement for FUJI) I mean, we kind of "know" its about...

[Feature]: Improve the reading of EML metadata

Ok, so I find these multiple URL or their reason of existence confusing, even as a human. Whatever there is going on with these multiple URL, it should be made...

Refer to Dataset as `Folder` or `Directory`

+1 to having the discussion - but feeling unease with adding `Directory` or `Folder` more explicitly in the spec. Simple reason: we do not need it. And yes, less *is*...

Refer to Dataset as `Folder` or `Directory`

I got carried away indeed :-) ### repeating my basic point What is not explicit enough about `hasPart`? To me: any enitity with those around is part of the hierarchy...

Proposal: Make v2 spec smaller and tighter and concentrate on named rules (with a code) of syntax and semantics of the RO-Crate-Metadata document from fundamentals

Late reaction: I like the spec-as-an-implementing-developer-guide idea. Clean target audience surely serves as a focal point, allowing to cut (move out) text to separate docs. Still, rereading after some time...

Convene a working group on implementation neutral Profiles, schemas, RO-Crate editor and documentation tools and validation

Sorry for coming in late to this discussion. Am finally reading up on the original contribution, and skimming part of the discussion. ... For now, I would mainly want to...