Kara Woo

I haven't touched jitterdodge so I don't really know, but looking at it I can't see any reason why `"group"` should not be included.

The latter issue about the margins for legend text/titles has been raised in #1502. I tried to tackle that after reworking `titleGrob()` last year, but wasn't able to wrap my...

I can reproduce the first error; the second two examples only throw a warning and create an empty plot.

Someone gave a lightning talk at the Seattle useR meetup on this topic a few months ago. He showed a few examples, one of which was [tableone](https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/tableone/index.html)

I think there are a couple of issues here that are recurring themes with dodging. One is that `position_dodge2()` doesn't work for point geoms at all, so every time you...

Yeah I think that's right, unfortunately

I think [this](https://github.com/tidyverse/ggplot2/blob/2dce9820faef8e1a8af6a7377fa0914f3ca7ab23/R/scale-.r#L255-L258) is the relevant section of code, and from that comment it looks like there was already an intention to change this behavior, maybe? I'll talk with Hadley...

My bad, that link is actually not the place where this happens, that's just for the scale breaks. Which I suppose I should have guessed based on the variable name...

Ok, I *think* [this](https://github.com/tidyverse/ggplot2/blob/d870275b7a6e0ab7aeaacfa1d92d4d2de3d6245f/R/scale-continuous.r#L129-L130) is the relevant section. The `oob` function defaults to [`scales::censor()`](https://github.com/hadley/scales/blob/6db7b6fa12b448129ef9380efa618d1963b4b0c9/R/bounds.r#L154-L162), which replaces out of bounds data with NAs, and then those NAs get replaced with whatever...

Does `geom_pointrange()` work? Or do you have a more complex use case that requires a separate point geom? ``` r library(ggplot2) df