Ebraheem Farag

The best solution to this is probably to just prevent users from using TDC with predictive mixing or present a warning to users.

It looks to me like you might be resolving He-subflashes in rc23.05.1. [Here](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wMbyi-kYhqxxred_Whhu5O8FI9-lO8Lr/view?usp=share_link)(edit fixed the link) is a movie of a solar Z, 2.1Msun model encountering sub-flashes in r15140 before...

I ran the inlists provided through both versions exactly as provided with the edits @evbauer suggested, and I can reproduce the same results, confirming that there are sub-flashes in rc23.05.1,...

> Are you referring to a specific example of he subflashes on the early agb? What statement are you referring to? Sorry, I know I wrote a lot. In general...

> Yeah agree, I'm happy for oscillations to occur around the actual helium shell flashes (just noting that the he flashes on the TP-AGB are not the same physical mechanism...

My bad, you are correct! On Fri, Jun 2, 2023 at 7:38 PM Giulia Catherine Cinquegrana < ***@***.***> wrote: > since the oscillations you are seeing precede he-core burning (the...

Just to quickly recap! We have He-core flashes, these strange He-shell flashes at the onset of the agb during he-shell burning, and then thin He-shell Thermal-pulses later on right? Not...

> So maybe that's an indication of an issue with the location of the base of the convective envelope when just using schwarschild. This [2.1Msun solar Z model (r15140)](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wMbyi-kYhqxxred_Whhu5O8FI9-lO8Lr/view?usp=share_link) was...

@mjoyceGR Lovely papers, thanks for sharing!

Hello @AldanaGrichener, thanks for documenting this so well and digging into the MESA code! If you'd like you can try [fix_rates_detailed_balance](https://github.com/MESAHub/mesa/compare/EbF/fix_rates_detailed_balance) a potentially working fix. Perhaps you could help verify...