Ashe Oro

The Engineering team has expressed quite a bit of concern over making a once immutable NFT mutable by overloading the supply key. On Wed, Feb 22, 2023, 7:46 PM Patches...

> I agree with this. The admin key could remove and rotate another key, but not add the key if it's not currently set. This allows additional trust when the...

> **2. If the admin key is removed, can lower privilege keys then remove themselves?** No, it still remains a lower privilege key that doesn't have the authority to remove...

> My two cents are that we should have a pathway for any key to remove itself, but I am happy to start with the admin key being able to...

> @michielmulders I did try to point out that my example is not perfect; and I understand many people can find flaws in it. It was late. > > However,...

> integrators agree that this could be 2 separate HIPs. It's a balancing act between (more scope & fewer) vs (less scope & more frequent). I'll bring it up with...

> Are there any 3rd party impartial risk scoring tools? I'm not aware of any other risk score calculators in the Hedera ecosystem.

> > NFT Risk Calculator: https://github.com/hashgraph/hedera-nft-utilities/tree/main/risk > > Are there any 3rd party impartial risk scoring tools? > > That's a great counter example you shared, thanks. also if you...

UPDATE: After giving time for community feedback on this HIP and thru several conversations with the SwirldsLabs Engineering team, I believe it's best to *NOT* include the ability for keys...

i think we need to either include both `approve` and `approveForAll` on the token or move both to the account. But consistency seems like the right play here.