rav1e icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
rav1e copied to clipboard

Support lossless mode!

Open ycho opened this issue 7 years ago • 9 comments

ycho avatar Mar 22 '18 02:03 ycho

Won't do this.

ycho avatar Aug 08 '18 22:08 ycho

Someone had an interesting use case of encoding MAME files, e.g. og.kervella.org/pt.7z

This is low priority but no reason not to implement it.

tdaede avatar Feb 12 '19 19:02 tdaede

Sure, rav1e always can encode losslessly. I believe AV1 do that with only using 4x4 DCTs as transform, correct?

ycho avatar Feb 12 '19 19:02 ycho

There's a special 4x4 transform that we currently don't have. That's the main thing missing.

tdaede avatar Feb 12 '19 19:02 tdaede

I've implemented support for importing and exporting AVIF images in darktable using libavif. I would be interested to have lossless support using rav1e.

https://blog.cryptomilk.org/2019/11/26/avif-image-support-for-darktable/

cryptomilk avatar Nov 26 '19 15:11 cryptomilk

We have added support for importing and exporting AVIF files in darktable which will be released with version 3.0.1. It would be great to have this fixed in rav1e soon.

cryptomilk avatar Dec 28 '19 09:12 cryptomilk

Any chance of this issue seeing some love?

eclipseo avatar Dec 10 '20 12:12 eclipseo

I'd like to voice my support for this feature as well :heart: :pray:

EDIT: I also realized that this issue is relevant to #2759, since aomenc can do lossless already.

CartoonFan avatar Sep 25 '22 05:09 CartoonFan

Just now seeing the recent commit here. Has there been any progress on lossless encoding? :eyes:

CartoonFan avatar Jan 08 '24 11:01 CartoonFan