html icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
html copied to clipboard

Adding document subtitle to the spec.

Open diekus opened this issue 2 years ago • 3 comments

Hola,

I am trying to add to the spec information of a new standardized meta name for subtitle. You can find context here. This would add a document.subtitle and a new standard name to the meta tags that would allow developers to specify contextual information of the running web app.

They constitute small changes and I am trying to understand if there is ant prettifier I should run on the source to make sure it is in the right format.

The current changes are in https://github.com/whatwg/html/compare/main...diekus:html:main, woudl you be so kind to guide me in what are the next seps I should do to get this into the spec?

Thank you

Diego

diekus avatar Feb 17 '23 19:02 diekus

The next steps are to get your change implemented in two engines, with agreement to ship.

domenic avatar Feb 18 '23 05:02 domenic

Hola @domenic ,

We've updated the document app-title feature. I've discussed the feature with our Webkit friends and as of now Mozilla's position about the feature is to defer and Webkit's is neutral.

I'd like to get some discussion ongoing about this feature in hopes of adding this value to the standard meta names registration, as the HTML spec reads "If the name is for something expected to have processing requirements in user agents; in that case it ought to be standardized." Since this value requires the UA to process and set the text after the application's name, then by definition it can't be set to the MetaExtensions and would need to be in the HTML spec under standard metadata names.

Considering there is no opposition to the proposal, and we've made changes to the initial API, I'm bringing back this topic to the top for discussion.

cc @dmurph @marcoscaceres @ngaitonde @zcorpan

diekus avatar Jun 11 '24 15:06 diekus

As per https://whatwg.org/working-mode#changes you'll need sufficient implementer interest which it seems like you don't have at the moment. (Although standards-positions is not always a proxy for what gets implemented, so maybe you do?)

annevk avatar Jun 11 '24 15:06 annevk

Since application-name exists in HTML, I think this should be named application-title instead of app-title for consistency.

zcorpan avatar Nov 11 '24 19:11 zcorpan

Is the an incubations repository for html that will let us submit the spec somewhere for reference?

dmurph avatar Dec 06 '24 23:12 dmurph

We usually do pull requests for that purpose.

domenic avatar Dec 07 '24 02:12 domenic

@zcorpan We've updated the name in the explainer and the change in the implementation should be landing any day now. Thanks for the feedback.

https://github.com/MicrosoftEdge/MSEdgeExplainers/blob/main/DocumentSubtitle/explainer.md

diekus avatar Dec 24 '24 14:12 diekus