website icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
website copied to clipboard

Molten Salt Fast Spectrum Reactors?

Open davidfetter opened this issue 5 years ago • 2 comments

Apparently, there are fast spectrum reactors, or at least designs for same, that use molten salt fuel. Is there enough there there to write something up one way or the other?

davidfetter avatar Jan 04 '21 07:01 davidfetter

yeah that's a good idea. They are mentioned briefly on the MSR page but could be expanded upon

partofthething avatar Sep 23 '22 04:09 partofthething

I don't know quite how to put this gently, but as far as I can tell, LFTR is a scam based on at best speculative extensions of the work done at Oak Ridge with multiple-weapon quantities of weapons grade ²³³U and one experiment with a teensy amount of thorium. Intractable problems other than that ²³³U required in order to get to criticality include:

  • A source of large amounts of highly enriched ⁷Li for the FLiBe, production of which also gets you large amounts of enriched ⁶Li, which is weapons material.
  • Credible ways to prevent diversion of the extremely pure ²³³Pa, which quickly turns into extremely pure ²³³U, that the thing will produce when fed thorium.
  • Steel that remains at best speculative, given the constraint that it can't have Co in it because of activation.
  • Automated processing on site that requires really nasty chemistry with fluorine and so is itself a huge chemical hazard.

I don't believe that LFTR has earned a page framed other than as "overwhelmingly likely a scam." It'd be good to have one on molten salt fast reactors, which at least are based on things that have a conceivable supply chain, etc., and if they turn out to be just as scammy, to mention that fact prominently.

davidfetter avatar Sep 23 '22 17:09 davidfetter