tkvdb icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
tkvdb copied to clipboard

Explicit License

Open DennisHeimbigner opened this issue 1 year ago • 4 comments

any chance of getting you to change to explicitly use and reference of of the standard licenses? BSD 3 clause would be a good choice. The reason I ask is that our code auditor for our project (unidata netcdf) uses a tool to ensure we only use a selected set of well known licenses, so using an explicit URL to point to a standard license website keeps the tool happy.

DennisHeimbigner avatar Nov 08 '24 05:11 DennisHeimbigner

Hello!

I'm not an expert in licenses, but it seems to me that ISC and BSD are almost the same. ISC is more permissive, that was the reason I chose it. Can you fork and relicense under another license (maybe under another name)? For me it would be quite ok. If I need to do something for this - feel free to text me, I will do it.

vmxdev avatar Nov 08 '24 07:11 vmxdev

Yes, if you could do that with some other name -- radixtrie perhaps -- using this URL as part of your license file: https://opensource.org/license/bsd-3-clause The reason I ask this has to with the way our software (Unidata/netcdf-c) gets audited. They are picky about the licenses for external software that we use. BTW I am going by the ratings on the Open Source Initiative web site: https://opensource.org/license They rate ISC as uncategorized (https://opensource.org/license/isc-license-txt).

DennisHeimbigner avatar Nov 08 '24 19:11 DennisHeimbigner

No, I will not fork, rename and relicense the library. I don't need it. You can do it. I meant that I can give special permissions if it is really necessary. You can even take the library and remove any mention of authorship, I really don’t care.

vmxdev avatar Nov 10 '24 18:11 vmxdev

FSF lists it: https://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-list.html#ISC "This license is sometimes also known as the OpenBSD License. It is a free software license, and compatible with the GNU"

ISC License (#ISC) "Free and GPL-Compatible License. "

The tool that lists it as "uncategorized" should be updated... (As should the Open Source Initiative web site...)

bogen85 avatar Nov 10 '24 19:11 bogen85