thoth-station
Bidirectional sync between project board columns and labels
Problem statement
As a Thoth developer, I would like to be able to filter issues by project board colum when :
- searching issues
- using the github API
- ...
Ex: gh search issues --project thoth-station/16 --label status:new
High-level Goals
- [ ] Issues on a project board searchable by project board column
Proposal description
I think there is some Github Actions which can do the bidirectionnal sync (update the labels when using the project board UI, update the project board when modifying the label) with two labels dimension (one for which project, one for which column), but I didn't investigate for now.
Alternatives
No change.
Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] "Project -> labels" sync works
- [ ] "labels -> Project" sync works
@VannTen: This issue is currently awaiting triage.
If a refinement session determines this is a relevant issue, it will accept the issue by applying the
triage/accepted label and provide further guidance.
The triage/accepted label can be added by org members by writing /triage accepted in a comment.
Instructions for interacting with me using PR comments are available here. If you have questions or suggestions related to my behavior, please file an issue against the kubernetes/test-infra repository.
sounds helpful, could you put an hour or so in and figure out if we can do it easily for our repos and https://github.com/orgs/open-services-group/projects/21/views/1
@schwesig
So, not that easy it would seem. From the github docs (workflows do not support org projects)[ https://docs.github.com/en/actions/using-workflows/events-that-trigger-workflows#project_card] (third note). Beside, I've seen several projects doing one of the sync direction, but not both.
So that would need at least some work.
I've not checked the new API for beta projects, but it might be relevant.
Related #424
/triage needs-information
Gitlab has issue boards which do exactly that.
Regarding the new project version, they don't appear to provide that functionality either. (might be in the API, but managing that ourselves seems more trouble than it's worth)
An earlier attempt to implement this using prow: https://github.com/thoth-station/thoth-application/pull/2450
This was only uni-directional (auto-add issues to project boards), and it's not really working though. Oh, and it is only meant to work with the "classic" projects, not the new ones.
Uni-directional meant everyone has to use the same process, though. It would certainly be simpler (as mentioned earlier, several github actions do just that).
I'll be fine with working only with labels as I'd rather use gh than the github UI, but I'm not sure everyone is a fan^.
Also, if we do decide that everyone should use one workflow, we should disable (with permissions or settings or whatever) the other, otherwise it will be used anyway ^.
|||
Maybe I should reframe this issue -> 'Uniform SIG assignations triage process & automation' or something like that.
EDIT: Can't do md in email reply. Wow, that's ... disappointing
Issues needing reporter input close after 60d,
If there is new input, reopen with /reopen.