blockstack-browser icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
blockstack-browser copied to clipboard

Dclouds and Dmail do not allow login with blockstack browser on Firefox

Open timstackblock opened this issue 6 years ago • 10 comments

Dclouds and Dmail do not allow login with blockstack browser on Firefox

The user can login successfully in chrome but when using firefox the screen loads forever and they are never taken into the app.

Please see the videos below.

http://www.trymyui.com/pva/88g1G67eOFLTtTP4 and http://www.trymyui.com/pva/886SsS7eOD1wV3zg

timstackblock avatar Nov 20 '19 20:11 timstackblock

Hey Tim - did you repro this? I was not able to repro with Dmails on Firefox. It's possible there was a network connection issue.

hstove avatar Nov 21 '19 00:11 hstove

I confirm that it is working smoothly, we tried to logout and login again with no problem.

we captured a video for the login process and here is the link if you would like to check.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1BZg0YjT2Ncf7MMzHBq3En1n4QppV2kV3/view?usp=sharing

Thanks

dmailonline avatar Nov 21 '19 15:11 dmailonline

  1. DCLOUD I was able to reproduce the error in Firefox with Dcloud it is a valid bug with dcloud and our browser. We have an auth issue redirecting back to Dcloud and the user gets an infinite spinner.

  2. DMAIL The Dmail issues is a bug on the Dmail side with out our browser. The link does not work in a Firefox browser even without our browser auth. Just going to the link itself is not possible in the Firefox browser.

timstackblock avatar Nov 22 '19 13:11 timstackblock

DMAIL

The link https://app.dmail.online/ does not work with a firefox browser the issue is not blockstack browser is it dmail rendering in Firefox even without our browser

Video of the bug: http://somup.com/cqX3FmfrM6

Screen Shot 2019-11-22 at 1 46 55 PM

timstackblock avatar Nov 22 '19 18:11 timstackblock

DCLOUD

The Dclouds bug however is an auth issue. When a user attempts to login with a blockstack ID they run into an infinite spinner in Firefox

Video of bug Auth: http://somup.com/cqX3FLfrMy

Screen Shot 2019-11-22 at 1 50 39 PM

timstackblock avatar Nov 22 '19 18:11 timstackblock

I've got the same issues, but with Brave & Firefox in win&linux

btsfav avatar Nov 23 '19 20:11 btsfav

Dclouds.online and dmail.online both work for me on Firefox 70.0.1 in Linux, Windows, and MacOS. The Linux and Windows tests were performed on fresh OS installations.

Is this bug still reproducible for anyone? Seems like it was a problem with those apps, and has since been fixed?

zone117x avatar Dec 03 '19 15:12 zone117x

I can reproduce this consistently with the web app in Firefox 70.0.1 Here is a video: http://somup.com/cqlh2ifvis

Lets zoom call so I can show you the bug, here is a screenshot of the error console as well.

Screen Shot 2019-12-05 at 8 50 40 AM

timstackblock avatar Dec 05 '19 14:12 timstackblock

The screenshot that @timstackblock included definitely looks like an error that would happen on the Dclouds side - their service worker is not being registered, and there are other exceptions as well.

hstove avatar Dec 05 '19 16:12 hstove

https://github.com/blockstack/blockstack-browser/issues/2028

timstackblock avatar Feb 28 '20 13:02 timstackblock