websocket-sharp icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
websocket-sharp copied to clipboard

Has this project been abandoned?

Open gtaylor44 opened this issue 6 years ago • 3 comments

This project has been in pre-release status (in Nuget) for close to 3-years and hasn't had an update in 2-years.

What are the plans for this project? Is .NET core support on the radar? Will it ever come out of pre-release status?

gtaylor44 avatar May 10 '19 09:05 gtaylor44

Apparently not. https://github.com/sta/websocket-sharp/network sta still actively maintaining this project. However, he is just stopped updating NUGET for unknown reason.

Nyconing avatar Nov 16 '19 06:11 Nyconing

@sta Can you please tell us about the plans related to nuget updates? The last nuget was downloaded ~350000 times, so there should be a lot of people being interested in the project.

imsh avatar Mar 03 '20 11:03 imsh

I'm also adding "my two cents" to that topic

Apparently not. https://github.com/sta/websocket-sharp/network sta still actively maintaining this project.

"Maintaining"... So let's have a look at the latest commits: https://github.com/sta/websocket-sharp/commits/master (or for people that read that comment in the future: https://github.com/sta/websocket-sharp/commits/master?after=4cbd1e0ccdbf9f5cb322a7c14e3c84e19db5dee1+0&branch=master )

Date Commit What was done
2021-01-01 https://github.com/sta/websocket-sharp/commit/4cbd1e0ccdbf9f5cb322a7c14e3c84e19db5dee1 Updated license to 2021
2021-01-01 https://github.com/sta/websocket-sharp/commit/34cb6432734df6cf4818ef1033b5e4cab6f37fc1 Added 14 new empty lines
2020-12-31 https://github.com/sta/websocket-sharp/commit/45db0ea4772c7befdd5df3e0b1a826cd42b81a1c Added 4 new empty lines
2020-12-30 https://github.com/sta/websocket-sharp/commit/605ae9173ea66d9b6c67c24d1cf41b79d9555f70 Added 7 new empty lines
2020-12-29 https://github.com/sta/websocket-sharp/commit/9a9b3e43bd2e0d10113fcdcbe2319281b4bbd58c Updated license year of a single file to 2020
2020-12-29 https://github.com/sta/websocket-sharp/commit/9a9ae4852d5beb49f317518a574c311e067c03e1 Removed an unused method
2020-12-28 https://github.com/sta/websocket-sharp/commit/747361a86f96c7dd16004bf7c64cc2bfecb9fa1c Added 5 new empty lines
...

There seem to be also some other changes that are making more sense, however i am unable to understand what they are doing, because

  • no issues or branches are used
  • the commits are information-less and always the same: [Modify] Replace it, [Modify] Edit it, [Modify] Add it, [Modify] Polish it, [Modify] <Year>

I can also not find any issue activity since 2017 or pr activity since 2016

The latest release to nuget was done in 2016, has ~500k downloads and is somehow a prerelease. There are also other versions, however most of them are older than one year and many hundred commits behind current code.

I also don't get it why someone would do nearly every day 1-3 commits, but never releases a update to nuget. (looks like bot-behavior for me...)

TL;DR This is one of the weirdest repositories that I have ever seen on GitHub so far. I don't know or can even imagine what @sta is doing or what he even tries to achieve...

With the current status - no feedback from the author and de-facto no support - i can't recommend using the library to anyone. Sad for such a great library.

I personally switched to a fork, so I have at least an .NET standard compatible lib.

IMHO

litetex avatar Jan 06 '21 16:01 litetex