safe-react icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
safe-react copied to clipboard

Create/signing txs with Ledger in safes 1.0.0

Open francovenica opened this issue 4 years ago • 3 comments

Description

Creating a tx or trying to sign (with no execution) cannot be done with a Ledger in a safe 1.0.0. An error in the console is shown

Environment

  • Browser: Chrome
  • Wallet: Ledger Nano S, but reports in the Ledger X were done as well
  • Safe and Environment:
    • Tested here: https://pr3184--safereact.review-safe.gnosisdev.com/app/rin:0xF79d94aE926529cbbe6cE7A10317ba68D65F66a7/transactions/queue
    • Reported here first: https://gnosis-safe.io/app/eth:0x30d3bbAE8623d0e9C0db5c27B82dCDA39De40997/balances

Steps to reproduce

  1. Create a tx in a safe 1.0.0 with a ledger
  2. Try to sign (with no execution) with a ledger in a safe 1.0.0

Expected result

The tx is created The tx signature is recorded

Obtained result

For both cases an error in the console is shown

Screenshots

image

francovenica avatar Dec 20 '21 13:12 francovenica

I suggest we close this as wontfix and ask users of Ledger and Safe 1.0.0 to upgrade. @johannesmoormann wdyt?

katspaugh avatar Jan 06 '22 13:01 katspaugh

@francovenica could you check if it works with MM? If yes, we can close this ticket and suggest upgrading the Safe.

johannesmoormann avatar Jan 17 '22 16:01 johannesmoormann

No, even by using the ledger account imported in MM I still get this error image

francovenica avatar Jan 18 '22 13:01 francovenica