group-sync-operator
group-sync-operator copied to clipboard
Name collision when synchronizing sub groups from Keycloak
Keycloak does not ensure uniqe group names for sub groups. When synchronized to OpenShift the behaviour is random.
Preconditions
Given the following group strucutre in Keyckloak:
"""
* group-a
** sub-group
* group-b
** sub-group
"""
And a user named "user-a" asigned to group "group-a/sub-group"
And a user named "user-b" asigned to group "group-b/sub-group"
When the groups are sync with the option "scope" set to "sub"
Observation
Then there are the following groups:
"""
* group-a
* group-b
* sub-group
"""
And the user list of "sub-group" contains "user-a"
Or the user list of "sub-group" contains "user-b"
Note that the bahaviour is random. Depending on unknown conditions, users are synced from either "group-a/sub-group" or "group-b/sub-group".
Expectations
Then there are the following groups:
"""
* group-a
* group-b
* group-a-sub-group
* group-b-sub-group
"""
And the user list of "group-a-sub-group" contains "user-a"
And the user list of "group-b-sub-group" contains "user-b"
In the above - got used as a separator to prepend the parents group name. I suggest to have this configurable.