protobuf-javascript icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
protobuf-javascript copied to clipboard

JS: Handling Infinity values for Float fields

Open serchavalos opened this issue 6 years ago • 1 comments

Hello!

I noticed that in encoder.js, the method does not allow writeFloat does not accept Infinity as its value

https://github.com/protocolbuffers/protobuf/blob/d9ccd0c0e6bbda9bf4476088eeb46b02d7dcd327/js/binary/encoder.js#L365-L375

/**
 * Writes a single-precision floating point value to the buffer. Numbers
 * requiring more than 32 bits of precision will be truncated.
 * @param {number} value The value to write.
 */
jspb.BinaryEncoder.prototype.writeFloat = function(value) {
  goog.asserts.assert((value >= -jspb.BinaryConstants.FLOAT32_MAX) &&
                      (value <= jspb.BinaryConstants.FLOAT32_MAX));
  jspb.utils.splitFloat32(value);
  this.writeUint32(jspb.utils.split64Low);
};

And its comment seems misleading because it says Numbers requiring more than 32 bits of precision will be truncated. but in reality, it throws an error.

Shouldn't writeFloat remove this restriction or at least this assert?

Thanks in advance,

serchavalos avatar May 17 '19 04:05 serchavalos

Yes, the API is a bit misleading and we should clean this up.

dibenede avatar Sep 16 '22 22:09 dibenede