tutorials icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
tutorials copied to clipboard

Convergence issue in nearest-projection mapping in fenics-fenics HT case for complex domain

Open IshaanDesai opened this issue 6 years ago • 2 comments

A convergence study was conducted for the tutorial HT/partitioned-heat/fenics-fenics with nearest-projection and nearest-neighbor mappings for a simple interface (linear edge interface parallel to Y-axis) and a complex interface (Circular interface bounded in a rectangular domain). The simple interface study shows good results of improvement from nearest-neighbor to nearest-projection. The complex domain is visualised as follow: Screenshot from 2019-10-23 08-00-14 The convergence study results are as follows: complex_interface_convergence It is seen that there is no significant improvement in the error plot when nearest-projection mapping is used instead of nearest-neighbor. One possible explanation is the error induced due to the RBF interpolation strategy being used contributes significantly to the total error and hence masks the effects of an improved mapping. Further investigation needs to be done.

IshaanDesai avatar Oct 23 '19 06:10 IshaanDesai

Further study:

  • Check convergence for non-matching meshes to get more insight in NN vs. NP performance
  • Solve complex geometry case in a monolithic way with single FEniCS participant to see if error arises from mesh setup or coupling

IshaanDesai avatar Jul 28 '20 07:07 IshaanDesai

This needs to be re-done with the latest tutorial and adapter code

IshaanDesai avatar Apr 14 '21 07:04 IshaanDesai