tsc icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
tsc copied to clipboard
verified publisher icon moby

Criteria of TSC Represented Projects?

Open AkihiroSuda opened this issue 8 years ago • 7 comments

https://github.com/moby/tsc/tree/4e9cd33666f71c55283a00f59ec78b76d525938a#tsc-represented-projects

It might be good to state clearly:

  • Criteria of TSC Represented Projects
  • How TSC represented / non-represented project can be added / deleted
  • How addition / deletion of TSC represented project affects the number of the existing committee seats

cc @crosbymichael @thaJeztah

AkihiroSuda avatar Sep 29 '17 03:09 AkihiroSuda

A lot of these details will be figured out after the TSC has been elected. We just need to bootstrap the process right now then this group can take it from there.

crosbymichael avatar Sep 29 '17 18:09 crosbymichael

Yes, however, I think some basic explanation about the criteria before bootstrapping would be appreciated for ensuring legitimacy of the bootstrap committee.

For example, why runc is not TSC represented while containerd is TSC represented?

AkihiroSuda avatar Sep 29 '17 23:09 AkihiroSuda

I imagine that's probably because runc is already governed entirely by the OCI now, and as such is not going to be governed as part of the "Moby" umbrella (even if it ends up being considered a Moby project -- the OCI is responsible for determining the governance of runc).

tianon avatar Oct 02 '17 21:10 tianon

How does it differ from CNCF containerd?

AkihiroSuda avatar Oct 04 '17 04:10 AkihiroSuda

Containerd still used the BDSL model; https://github.com/containerd/containerd/blob/3596ec53ab24046aaa67da2d392857fc888a6078/MAINTAINERS#L119-L148

thaJeztah avatar Oct 04 '17 11:10 thaJeztah

CNCF does not enforce a governance model on its projects.

cpuguy83 avatar Oct 24 '17 14:10 cpuguy83

Any progress on this?

AkihiroSuda avatar Dec 10 '19 06:12 AkihiroSuda