misskey icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
misskey copied to clipboard

Make entire post clickable

Open ThatOneCalculator opened this issue 3 years ago • 16 comments

Summary

Most (if not all) other SNS's have it so clicking/tapping anywhere on a post expands the post, many new users find it unintuitive/confusing to have to click just the timestamp.

ThatOneCalculator avatar Jun 09 '22 02:06 ThatOneCalculator

Most (if not all) other SNS's have it so clicking/tapping anywhere on a post expands the post

This does not seem to be the case for Pleroma. It behaves similarly to Misskey in that you have to click on the timestamp to get to the page of the post.

I think it might also cause issues in conjunction with the timeline automatically scrolling down when new notes appear.

In my personal opinion it is also annoying if you e.g. want to copy a piece of text from a post and do not need to go to the posts page.

Johann150 avatar Jun 13 '22 09:06 Johann150

Misskey Tweaks does it in a fairly elegant way, you can still select text and not enter a post, but clicking on the post body takes you into the replies.

Also,

This does not seem to be the case for Pleroma. It behaves similarly to Misskey in that you have to click on the timestamp to get to the page of the post.

Pleroma FE is probably the least user-friendly FE for any SNS, especially for people new to the Fediverse.

ThatOneCalculator avatar Jun 13 '22 15:06 ThatOneCalculator

Most (if not all) other SNS's have it so clicking/tapping anywhere on a post expands the post

This does not seem to be the case for Pleroma. It behaves similarly to Misskey in that you have to click on the timestamp to get to the page of the post.

I think it might also cause issues in conjunction with the timeline automatically scrolling down when new notes appear.

In my personal opinion it is also annoying if you e.g. want to copy a piece of text from a post and do not need to go to the posts page.

I don't think anyone wants selecting text to expand the post, they want a twitter-like experience.

viasux avatar Oct 30 '22 18:10 viasux

やるか

syuilo avatar Nov 12 '22 22:11 syuilo

If you look at Calckey's implementation and like it, I could PR it :)

ThatOneCalculator avatar Nov 12 '22 22:11 ThatOneCalculator

If you look at Calckey's implementation and like it, I could PR it :)

It's nice but it's not very easy to understand, the cursor has to turn into a hand over clickable areas. I understood how it works by mistake. We have done this modification in our calckey instance, it you want I could ask Jon to PR this to you first, works nicely.

panosda avatar Nov 14 '22 21:11 panosda

Yea, if you could PR it that'd be great

ThatOneCalculator avatar Nov 14 '22 21:11 ThatOneCalculator

I chose to improve the menu and make the entire post clickable https://github.com/misskey-dev/misskey/pull/9165#issuecomment-1312589897

@syuilo make the entire post clickable はもう実装されてる? ただco.misskey.io と p1.a9z.dev でノートをタッチしたけど詳細ページが表示されなかった

futchitwo avatar Jan 08 '23 11:01 futchitwo

されてない

syuilo avatar Jan 08 '23 11:01 syuilo

現時点でする必要性もそこまで感じてない

syuilo avatar Jan 08 '23 11:01 syuilo

メニューや時間から行けるし要らないと思う

syuilo avatar Jan 15 '23 05:01 syuilo

えー

futchitwo avatar Jan 15 '23 13:01 futchitwo

リアクションしようとしたときにレイアウトシフトが起きると投稿をクリックしたことになって遷移が発生することになるのはストレスになりそう

syuilo avatar Mar 02 '23 09:03 syuilo

どうなんでしょう、、 リアクションしようとしてレイアウトシフトした時って大抵ノートが画面外に行ってて探す手間があるので もし遷移してくれたら個人的には嬉しいかもと思ったり…

tsaito18 avatar Mar 02 '23 10:03 tsaito18

投稿をクリックして投稿ページを開けてタイムラインに戻ったら以前の位置を失う問題を先に解決しないとかなりストレスになるかもです

saschanaz avatar Mar 02 '23 13:03 saschanaz

個人的な話として断ると、タッチデバイスでスクロールする際に稀にタッチ判定されてスクロールが阻害されたり、投稿内テキストを選択できなくなる UI への体験がすごく悪いので、例えタップして遷移するケースがそこそこあったとて使いやすいかは別だと思う

acid-chicken avatar Mar 02 '23 13:03 acid-chicken