fluentui-emoji icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
fluentui-emoji copied to clipboard

Include list of lissing emoji

Open Arithmomaniac opened this issue 3 years ago • 5 comments

As noted on Ars Technica:

There are just a few Microsoft designs that it hasn't open sourced, including the paperclip that looks like Clippy (the character is apparently copyrighted). A couple of other emoji were excluded because Microsoft's versions exclude [sic] the Windows logo.

The README (or some other file) should include a list of what such emoji from the Emoji standard are missing,

Arithmomaniac avatar Aug 11 '22 07:08 Arithmomaniac

At a minimum, this information from the announcement blog post should be noted somewhere:

I don’t want to sugarcoat, so let’s start with the bad news: Clippy isn’t included in the open source emoji set 😩. I know, and I’d personally love to but due to (legal speak, legal speak, legal speak), we can’t open-source trademarks. For the same reason, our country flags, video game, and technologist emoji also won’t be available.

Arithmomaniac avatar Aug 11 '22 07:08 Arithmomaniac

@Arithmomaniac - no problem:

  • All country flags & regional indicators - Microsoft doesn't use flags, as they can be a hard space to navigate politically.
  • Paperclip - because it looks like Clippy, who is trademarked.
  • Technologist - Our version has a laptop with a Windows logo. We're looking at updating so we can include.
  • Video game - Our version looked a little too close to an Xbox controller. We're looking at updating so we can include.
  • Any customizable variants. We're still working on a way to be able to customize and output these. This includes:
  • Handshake
  • Holding hands
  • Kiss
  • Couple
  • Family

jasoncuster avatar Aug 12 '22 14:08 jasoncuster

All country flags

@jasoncuster im curious, does that include the Regional Indicator emoji? I believe windows just renders them as small capital letters whereas most other emoji sets use some sort of special formatting.

bignutty avatar Aug 12 '22 19:08 bignutty

@jasoncuster thanks for the list and explanations; I hope it's added to source repo for visibility :-)

Is there a formal definition of a "customizable variant"? If not, what do you mean - those that support different skin tones?

Arithmomaniac avatar Aug 14 '22 06:08 Arithmomaniac

@justsomederpystuff Yes, I've updated the list to include Regional Indicators. @Arithmomaniac - currently we don't have a way to automate output of customizable variants. Some are smaller amount of variants, but when it comes to families, its thousands of options, hence us needing a way to build out exporting smarts instead of throwing each variant up here. It's something we'll get to at some point though.

jasoncuster avatar Sep 07 '22 01:09 jasoncuster