lowRISC
[edn] V1 Signoff
Description
Ensure V1 signoff criteria are fulfilled after focus area changes have landed.
@vogelpi / @h-filali - When you have a chance could you revise the expected effort. Remember that this is to V1 level
Sorry for the delay @johngt , there is no effort left for EDN at all. @h-filali did all the DD and DV work. What's left is just the sign-off and I will aim to keep everything at D2S/V2S.
I'll revise the estimate now.
@vogelpi: For a V1 signoff I think we don't need the DV stats. The smoke test still passes according to current nightly results, and if the changes made to EDN as part of M2 are covered either by existing tests or by additional testplan items (with issues to track their completion in M4/M5), then I think this can be closed as completed.
The V2S signoff can be done post M2. If the V2S signoff can be closed today, that's fine -- otherwise I'd prefer not gating M2 on a V2S signoff that's not strictly needed for M2.
I have now prepared the D2/D2S signoff and as part of that studied the criteria for V2/V2S. @h-filali worked very hard to update the DV inline with the RTL for M2 and we are very close to V2S except for one test which has a pass rate below the bar (85% vs 90%) and the FSM coverage is also below the bar (82% vs 90%), see below.
Thus, we have to sign off at V1 unfortunately.
Fixing the two things is tracked in #20818 and #22352. And the PR to lower the verification stage back to V1 is here: #22353.