ideas icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
ideas copied to clipboard

Test various power supplies

Open meeDamian opened this issue 7 years ago • 8 comments

Buy different ones, and try to abuse them. See which ones handle apocalypse the best.

meeDamian avatar Feb 24 '19 03:02 meeDamian

  • Official Raspberry PSU (5.1V 3A) is good

  • One bought at Computer Plaza for 79 baht is not good enough, undervoltage with 3 USB sticks attached. 1.5A, 5V

  • Bought one at 7-Eleven, 200 baht, 2A, 5V, works okay

AnotherDroog avatar Feb 24 '19 03:02 AnotherDroog

I was primarily referring to what @NoahO mentioned during our meeting in Cube7: Test how these power supplies would handle abuse in a form of power spikes etc.

meeDamian avatar Feb 24 '19 04:02 meeDamian

Perhaps we can research electrical testing certifications and only use chargers approved by certain schemes? Setting up an electronics testing lab is bit out of scope for us..

noaho avatar Feb 24 '19 05:02 noaho

Right, that's much faster, cheaper and better 😅.

meeDamian avatar Feb 24 '19 05:02 meeDamian

Not sure about certifications we can rely on, especially with all the knock-offs and garbage around.

We can do our own tests:

  • test voltage is >4.8V (undervoltage cutoff)
  • check there is 2A of current available

AnotherDroog avatar Feb 24 '19 06:02 AnotherDroog

My point was that a lot of these chargers are cheaply made, and might go open circuit (eg 220V all the way to the USB port) if they fail/get exposed to a surge, etc and blow up everything connected.

But my real point was that we can't rely on connected USB drives for funds backup - it wasn't about hardware reliability. Even good chargers can die.

noaho avatar Feb 24 '19 08:02 noaho

Maybe another thing we can do, is expose to the user when the power throttling is being hit on the pi, either by email notification or dashboard notification.

You could also argue that the Pi does a really good job of throttling, and it shouldn’t be that much slower if they use a lower amperage PSU..

noaho avatar Feb 25 '19 10:02 noaho

Yes great idea, undervoltage detection will need #78 to work

AnotherDroog avatar Mar 04 '19 09:03 AnotherDroog