xpool icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
xpool copied to clipboard

Have you compressed the LSMDC dataset?

Open Cola-any opened this issue 2 years ago • 5 comments

Excuse me,thank you for your excellent project. I have successfully reproduced it on two datasets, MSRVTT and MSVD.

But when I reproduced it on the LSMDC dataset, the performance was much worse than yours. After analysis, I think it may be because I compressed the LSMDC dataset, lowered the frame rate fps=3, and resize resolution to 224*298.

So I would like to consult you whether you have performed similar processing on the LSMDC dataset in your experiments. Thankyou so much!

Cola-any avatar Sep 18 '23 02:09 Cola-any

对不起,谢谢你的优秀项目。我已经成功地在两个数据集上重现了它,MSRVTT 和 MSVD。

但是当我在 LSMDC 数据集上重现它时,性能比你的差得多。经过分析,我认为可能是因为我压缩了 LSMDC 数据集,降低了帧率 fps=3,并将分辨率调整为 224*298。

因此,我想咨询您是否在实验中对 LSMDC 数据集进行了类似的处理。非常感谢!

请问您能分享一下LSMDC数据集吗,我没有权限下载,希望您能将文件分享到[email protected]。非常感谢您

LHlh917 avatar Nov 25 '23 06:11 LHlh917

@overwhelmedxh , have you reproduced the results on LSMDC dataset ? I doubt the compression may be the key factor which influence the retrieval results

JingXiaolun avatar Nov 25 '23 07:11 JingXiaolun

对不起,谢谢你的优秀项目。我已经成功地在两个数据集上重现了它,MSRVTT 和 MSVD。 但是当我在 LSMDC 数据集上重现它时,性能比你的差得多。经过分析,我认为可能是因为我压缩了 LSMDC 数据集,降低了帧率 fps=3,并将分辨率调整为 224*298。 因此,我想咨询您是否在实验中对 LSMDC 数据集进行了类似的处理。非常感谢!

请问您能分享一下LSMDC数据集吗,我没有权限下载,希望您能将文件分享到[email protected]。非常感谢您

I'm very sorry that I can't share the dataset with you personally, as it requires you to apply for permission from the owner. Please refer to https://sites.google.com/site/describingmovies/download

Cola-any avatar Nov 27 '23 02:11 Cola-any

@overwhelmedxh , have you reproduced the results on LSMDC dataset ? I doubt the compression may be the key factor which influence the retrieval results

Not yet. Our findings are consistent with yours.

Cola-any avatar Nov 27 '23 02:11 Cola-any

@overwhelmedxh, can you share your training log of LSMDC with me? [email protected]. Thanks in advance

JingXiaolun avatar Nov 27 '23 06:11 JingXiaolun