CIOD icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
CIOD copied to clipboard

Results not reproducable?

Open manoja328 opened this issue 6 years ago • 2 comments

Hello CIOD authors,

I was trying to run your code on VOC but couldnot reporduce the results with the command that was given in the repo. Are there any specific hyperparameters that I need to change to reporduce the results in the paper. With the deafult settings I only get the following for VOC:

========== RCNN Test set Summary (mAP, AP, %) NOREPR NEW ========== 66.77 : 76.27 77.38 71.37 61.54 47.27 58.15 : 48.92 69.31 53.01 38.05 25.31 67.56 82.25 80.12 43.44 73.47 32.62 : 12.42 17.92 20.97 15.87 16.40 42.24 53.29 20.44 15.03 22.77 36.49 49.47 69.63 24.23 72.08 25.76 : 12.61 11.40 10.18 10.13 6.16 7.87 39.36 31.07 6.06 5.07 5.70 21.64 53.77 35.47 52.51 29.91 31.24 52.66 42.50 49.89 ========== RCNN Test set Group Summary (mAP, AP, %) NEW NOREPR ========== Group 0 : 66.77 -> 46.92 -> 16.72 -> 10.09 Group 1 : 69.37 -> 30.75 -> 17.89 Group 2 : 50.38 -> 33.82 Group 3 : 41.24

manoja328 avatar Jan 10 '20 16:01 manoja328

Hi~

Please try to checkout commit d58255605e37e362ee746637fe93efb669a7e7ab.

Actually, no tricks, no specific hyper-parameters.

jinyu121 avatar Jan 16 '20 04:01 jinyu121

Hi, I checkout commit d58255605e37e362ee746637fe93efb669a7e7ab, and the result cannot reproduce either. ========== RCNN Test set Summary (mAP, AP, %) NOREPR NEW ========== 55.99 : 68.03 77.50 65.89 42.34 26.19 51.84 : 32.66 46.17 44.88 32.98 20.19 66.97 77.00 84.69 38.08 74.83 42.74 : 20.14 30.03 34.22 24.78 25.12 55.58 39.10 62.23 18.98 28.70 31.66 70.8068.01 60.91 70.80 40.17 : 18.12 28.53 36.02 25.88 22.35 17.68 49.11 50.75 20.00 29.34 18.67 57.6067.06 54.68 60.44 28.74 45.39 57.46 56.05 59.46 ========== RCNN Test set Group Summary (mAP, AP, %) NEW NOREPR ========== Group 0 : 55.99 -> 35.38 -> 26.86 -> 26.18 Group 1 : 68.31 -> 40.92 -> 33.38 Group 2 : 60.44 -> 51.69 Group 3 : 49.42

which has a huge gap with the result in paper. Can you reproduce the result on your server and help me figure out the problem? Thanks!

wassryan avatar Feb 20 '21 03:02 wassryan