lua icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
lua copied to clipboard

High-scores has high cognitive load for new Lua users (mentoring feedback)

Open glennj opened this issue 2 years ago • 1 comments

High-Scores is quite early in the list of exercises. It's probably the first one to introduce colon notation and the idea of a function returning a table with functions. I've had a few mentoring sessions where the user was pretty lost.

I don't have any concrete suggestions at the moment. Some thoughts:

  • add an introduction.md.append file to discuss:
    • closures and/or OOP in Lua
    • return values from modules
    • colon notation versus dot notation
  • flesh out the stub file a bit
  • move the exercise later in the list of exercises and/or bump the difficulty

glennj avatar Dec 06 '23 14:12 glennj

Examples:

  • https://exercism.org/mentoring/requests/71934aafebe9427db0e59257d59eb4b1
  • https://discord.com/channels/854117591135027261/1181639884360912956 and the corresponding https://exercism.org/mentoring/requests/cc9f908f8dd34af5ba7b245a2cf08dce

glennj avatar Dec 06 '23 14:12 glennj

Thanks for the feedback. I'll flesh out the stub, bump the difficulty, and move it so that it comes after Binary Search.

ryanplusplus avatar Sep 07 '24 00:09 ryanplusplus