sdscom-xml icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
sdscom-xml copied to clipboard

Support multiple instances of physical properties

Open kderhan opened this issue 1 year ago • 3 comments

Is it planned to store physical properties multiple times, so that, for example, different states of aggregation can be saved depending on the temperature?

Thx

kderhan avatar Oct 11 '24 07:10 kderhan

Discussed in today's workgroup meeting: Different physical states should be covered in different safety data sheets, because a product must be described in its delivery state. But for various other properties, it makes sense to allow multiple values depending on temperature and pressure. The We will consult the phrase workgroup and its experts and double-check where multiple instances should be possible.

dirk-qualisys avatar Oct 15 '24 16:10 dirk-qualisys

Brainstorming in today's phrase meeting: a change in physical state would cause other changes, like EUH211/212 or even GHS classification, transport classification, risk management measures. This would require a separate SDS to be consistent. There are borderline cases e.g. with a melting point of 25°C, but in such a case the supplier needs to decide based on temperature (penetrometer test according to ADR/RID). So, multiple entries of the physical state should not be supported.

For physical properties, it might make sense to submit information for other conditions (temperatures and/or pressures) than the delivery state. So multiple instances make sense whereever we have temperature and pressure conditions are relevant.

dirk-qualisys avatar May 21 '25 09:05 dirk-qualisys

Feedback from an eSDScom chemical expert: The following endpoints are not temperature-dependent and not pressure dependent, so need only a single instance (while all others should allow for multiple instances):

  • Appearance
  • Odour
  • Odour threshold
  • Flammability
  • Lower and upper explosion limit
  • Flash point
  • Auto-ignition temperature
  • Decomposition temperature
  • Particle characteristics
  • Mechanical sensitivity
  • Self-accelerating polymerization temperature (SAPT)
  • Formation of explosible dust/air mixtures
  • Acid/alkaline reserve
  • Conductivity
  • Corrosiveness
  • Properties of explosive atmospheres (gases/vapours)
  • Redox potential
  • Radical formation potential
  • Photocatalytic properties
  • Solvent content
  • Water content
  • Solid content
  • Propellant content
  • Acid number
  • Gel permeation chromatography (GPC)
  • Solvent separation test

dirk-qualisys avatar Oct 27 '25 17:10 dirk-qualisys