performance icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
performance copied to clipboard

writing a tutorial paper on intro to R^2 measures and their computation with `performance` package

Open IndrajeetPatil opened this issue 4 years ago • 17 comments

IndrajeetPatil avatar Jul 28 '21 17:07 IndrajeetPatil

For recent discussion #332 #334

bwiernik avatar Jul 28 '21 21:07 bwiernik

Hi @mkshaw! 👋

Do you think you would be interested in helping with this?

Should be right down your alley 🙃

IndrajeetPatil avatar Jul 31 '22 14:07 IndrajeetPatil

@IndrajeetPatil it does look like it's down my alley! I recently published this tutorial paper on R2s in MLMs using examples to show how to calculate and interpret output. It could be useful to have something similar for the various R2s available in performance: a top-level summary of all the measures available and generally how they differ/why we offer them, and then examples one-by-one showing their computation and interpretation.

What are your thoughts on this structure, and @bwiernik based on your discussions in #332 and #334 it seems like you're quite familiar with the measures already, would you be interested in collaborating on this?

mkshaw avatar Aug 03 '22 14:08 mkshaw

Yes, that would be great! Do you think you could start by putting together an outline or a draft and starting a pull request?

bwiernik avatar Aug 04 '22 14:08 bwiernik

@mkshaw Are you still interested in working on this? Thanks.

IndrajeetPatil avatar Oct 05 '23 10:10 IndrajeetPatil

@IndrajeetPatil I am still interested. I have my dissertation proposal next week, then can flesh out the outline. What software do you recommend for collaborating on this paper? I usually just write in Word, but if I'm starting a pull request and it's larger-scale collaboration, I imagine something else might be prefereable.

mkshaw avatar Nov 30 '23 18:11 mkshaw

@mkshaw Would you be comfortable collaborating on GitHub itself? You can have a look at this PR where we are collaborating to write a new paper.

As for software, we can use RMarkdown to generate a PDF (probably via rticles) we can use for journal submission.

IndrajeetPatil avatar Nov 30 '23 19:11 IndrajeetPatil

@IndrajeetPatil Happy to do that, I just need some help getting started, haven't done that before. Looking at the first commit from that PR, did you write the outline in RMarkdown locally, export to pdf, then upload the Rmd, md, and pdf files manually? And then people edit the md from there?

mkshaw avatar Nov 30 '23 19:11 mkshaw

I'd suggest using Word, since any revisions usually need to be submitted as "tracked changed" anyway, and "tracked changes" feature isn't really comfortable with markdown, even not for collaboration.

strengejacke avatar Nov 30 '23 19:11 strengejacke

@strengejacke okay so you recommend pull the Word doc from GitHub, edit locally, push?

mkshaw avatar Nov 30 '23 19:11 mkshaw

Yes, or even a Google docs file (or Word online). It depends on your workflow, pushing/pulling from GitHub is ok, too, I think.

strengejacke avatar Nov 30 '23 20:11 strengejacke

Google Docs online works for me and is perhaps the easiest. @bwiernik we had talked about collaborating on this, do you have a preference?

mkshaw avatar Nov 30 '23 20:11 mkshaw

This (and the links therein) can help you get started: https://easystats.github.io/performance/articles/r2.html

If we use a Word document, we could use Google Docs and collaborate there.

IndrajeetPatil avatar Nov 30 '23 20:11 IndrajeetPatil

No preference

bwiernik avatar Nov 30 '23 21:11 bwiernik

Does anyone know how to share a google doc file that has people request access to view? I don't want to create an anyone-can-edit link, but I don't have your email addresses to send specific access. It would be best to create a link you can click to request access, but that doesn't seem possible.

mkshaw avatar Dec 08 '23 23:12 mkshaw

If you share the url as-is (say, copied from the browser) it should have that effect.

mattansb avatar Dec 09 '23 11:12 mattansb

Let me know if this works, barebones outline: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1AUWxoTyvRdDA-gjvnWNRlbh5DDZ6dYug/edit?rtpof=true

mkshaw avatar Dec 11 '23 19:12 mkshaw