gnucash-android icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
gnucash-android copied to clipboard

How to add currencies (like crypto)?

Open dannywillems opened this issue 8 years ago • 4 comments

I would like to manage my different crypto-wallets. FTM, I use XXX and I use the currency in the account name. Is it possible to add a user-defined currency? At the end, I would like to be able to transfert between accounts with different currencies and mention a conversion rate. Is it possible now?

I'm motivated to help to contribute if I can have a brief description of the project and some advice to begin to implement it.

dannywillems avatar Sep 17 '17 14:09 dannywillems

@dannywillems Thanks for the feedback and willingness to contribute. User-defined currencies are not hard to implement in the app. It would basically amount to adding a view to input the data and then adding a record in the database.

It is more of a question of if we should do it. BTC was added in a recent release and that was highly requested. I've not heard much for totally custom commodities. Given the limited resources we have, we need to prioritize features.

@rivaldi8 what do you think? Is this a direction we should go?

codinguser avatar Sep 28 '17 12:09 codinguser

@codinguser As you say, it would require little code. So, in this respect, I wouldn't oppose to adding it. However, I also think this is a feature that very few user will need, but is a little more UI clutter that will affect all users as well as a little more code to maintain.

In my opinion, this a low priority use case already covered by GnuCash desktop, so there's is no urgent need for it in Android. Users can add the currency from the desktop and import it in Android. If more users ask for it, like with BTC, it can always be implemented.

In summary, I would rather not add the feature now, but I'm totally ok if you decide otherwise :)

rivaldi8 avatar Sep 30 '17 10:09 rivaldi8

I agree with @rivaldi8 , we would not pursue this for now. But I'll leave this issue open for now.

codinguser avatar Nov 10 '17 15:11 codinguser

Wouldn't this also mean you can import stocks and the like from the desktop version?

LivInTheLookingGlass avatar Oct 21 '21 04:10 LivInTheLookingGlass