ckeditor4 icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
ckeditor4 copied to clipboard
verified publisher icon ckeditor

[Accessibility] - Screen reader reads unnecessary contents before reading the textbox aria-label in a dialog while navigating with tab key

Open sryarama opened this issue 5 years ago • 6 comments

Type of report

Bug

Provide detailed reproduction steps (if any)

  1. Launch CKEditor 4 demo URL https://ckeditor.com/ckeditor-4/demo/
  2. Click on image toolbar item to open image dialog.
  3. Open NVDA.
  4. Tab till "URL" and "Alternative Text" field.
  5. Check whether it reads unnecessary contents before reading the aria-label of textbox.

Expected result

Screenraeder reads unnecessary contents before reading the field name while navigating through tab key. Issue is observed in Chrome + NVDA and ChromiumEdge+Narrator

Actual result

Screenreader should not read unnecessary contents before reading the field name while navigating through tab key.

Other details

  • Browser: Chorme, Chromium based EDGE
  • OS: Windows 10
  • CKEditor version: 4
  • Installed CKEditor plugins: Image
  • Screen reader: NVDA, Narrator.

Note: Attached video recording for the same.

https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/66038900/105109898-52642b00-5a72-11eb-891e-e3bf23cb3921.mp4

sryarama avatar Jan 20 '21 00:01 sryarama

It's been a while since we last heard from you. We are marking this issue as stale due to inactivity. Please provide the requested feedback or the issue will be closed after next 7 days.

github-actions[bot] avatar Jan 27 '21 09:01 github-actions[bot]

Hi, @sryarama ,

Thank you for your report.

I can only confirm ChromiumEdge + Narrator.
For Chrome + NVDA I can't experience such an issue. What kind of version of NVDA you are using? I use NVDA 2020.3 to verify, but I wasn't able to get the same results as yours.

Could you provide more details about your configuration that might be helpful? Like NVDA version, non-standard NVDA settings, more detailed CKEditor version, or browser build number.

sculpt0r avatar Jan 27 '21 11:01 sculpt0r

@sculpt0r - Thank you for confirming the issue on ChromiumEdge + Narrator. Below are the requested details for NVDA: NVDA version - 2020.3 (no changes to the default settings). CKEditor version - 4.11.4

sryarama avatar Jan 28 '21 20:01 sryarama

Thank you @sryarama for the details.
I must apologize, since it appears I tested it on NVDA + Firefox, instead of Chrome...

However, I mark both cases as a valid report. Also, I can confirm it on 4.16.0. Please, notice that we won't make any back-patches.

Thank you for your effort. Also, @Comandeer could you look at the expected result in such cases?

sculpt0r avatar Jan 28 '21 21:01 sculpt0r

Hi Team, is there any update on this? It is impacting our accessibility compliance.

sryarama avatar Aug 16 '21 17:08 sryarama

Hey @sryarama, so far we have no progress on this issue due to other priorities in CKEditor 4.

If you looking for a way to push this issue forward, you may contact our support team to see if there are any options to speed things up.

jacekbogdanski avatar Aug 17 '21 07:08 jacekbogdanski