age icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
age copied to clipboard

Support for apache tinkerpop gremlin

Open thirumalx opened this issue 3 years ago • 9 comments

Support for apache tinkerpop gremlin would be a nice feature with PostgreSQL. Any plan to support the gremlin in the future?

thirumalx avatar Dec 26 '22 16:12 thirumalx

There was some discussion for gremlin being supported by AGE in the early stages. We gotta reopen this discussion. because the original discussion happened before AGE was donated to Apahce

JoshInnis avatar Dec 31 '22 16:12 JoshInnis

are there news to it? now 1 year later?

paule96 avatar Feb 07 '24 19:02 paule96

@paule96 I am not familiar with Gremlin. It seems Gremlin supports Neo4j. Will it be possible to reuse it for AGE, because both AGE and Neo4J uses Cypher as a query language.

rafsun42 avatar Feb 08 '24 20:02 rafsun42

@rafsun42 the support for neo4j is deprecated for gremlin. So I don't think so.

paule96 avatar Feb 08 '24 20:02 paule96

@paule96 @rafsun42 This sounds like we would need to work with ATPG to implement it for AGE. Is there any interest on their side?

jrgemignani avatar Feb 20 '24 22:02 jrgemignani

I don't think the neo4j-gremlin module will be of much help. You'd need to implement it from scratch, but generally speaking it's interfaces are quick to implement. The hard part comes in optimization and working through Gremlin semantics issues to ensure the full Gremlin test suite executes, but I've seen basic implementations go up in as little as a week. We'd be happy to help guide you on this work.

I'd also like to renew my offer to have folks from AGE join the TinkerPop Twitch stream some time to talk a bit about their graph database:

https://lists.apache.org/thread/oo0xo6pqlr2mk6rp2gqrw5g1ntx9z1r2

spmallette avatar Feb 20 '24 22:02 spmallette

@spmallette I wasn't aware that TP had extended that offer. I will bring this up with the team and others.

jrgemignani avatar Feb 21 '24 00:02 jrgemignani

Do we have any update on Gremlin support for AGE

dianaoa22 avatar May 08 '24 11:05 dianaoa22