Adrian Gropper

The role of holder is the same as requester. An entity requests a VC from an issuer and may provide scope as well as authentication as part of the request....

It's not bike shedding to consider a directed request-based model vs. the current discussion of undirected and directed.

There are significant human rights associations with the `holder` term because of the temptation to use a biometric wallet or, more literally, an ankle bracelet. "Client credentials" is a constant...

I suggest a two-step process. Regardless of 1.1, 1.2, or v2, can we have a list of reasons why Holder is a normative term in the spec? If we had...

@TallTed - Thank you for engaging. On Wed, Sep 29, 2021 at 3:29 PM Ted Thibodeau Jr ***@***.***> wrote: > @agropper -- I've numbered these because > assigning letter-number pairs...

@Joe Andrieu ***@***.***> I think much of the discussion around holder is bikeshedding that does not adequately consider the confusion of contexts and interests for VCs https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-credentials/2022Sep/0046.html On Wed, Sep...

and my point is that using the same term across both issue and verification is a confusing strategy relative to the big picture of VC adoption. (I understand that my...

I totally agree and support the imperative that issuers SHOULD NOT be aware of verification. It's critical that all normative aspects of VCs be consistent with this separation. My concerns...

How is the mDL Holder == subject identified? Is there a biometric in the credential the way we have in a physical license? On Thu, Aug 12, 2021 at 12:29...

There's a huge difference between a picture of a person and control of a link secret or private key. I can't share my Driver's License (or mDL) with another person...