usbguard icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
usbguard copied to clipboard
verified publisher icon USBGuard

USB-C behavior & potential bypasses

Open pdolinic opened this issue 3 years ago • 4 comments

Even though USB-C connected devices show as blocked usbguard list-devices, they appear visible on the Linux file-system tree (thunar for example), (try it via a phone USB-C -> USB-C)

Some investigation might be worth there, and if one could exploit simply adding USB-C Dongles on top of USB-A/USB-B.

The first time I found this interesting, was when playing around with USB-C Yubikeys.

pdolinic avatar Dec 23 '22 16:12 pdolinic

Hi @pdolinic, maybe its just me but I think a few pictures and/or shell output would help to better understand the blocked-and-not-blocked situation that you're describing. Could you demonstrate for a particular device what parts of the system show that's blocked in detail and what parts don't? E.g. I'm unsure if we're talking a mounted file system here or more existence of a /dev/foo block device and so on. More details would be great. Thank you!

hartwork avatar Dec 23 '22 16:12 hartwork

Hey @hartwork , thanks for replying

So I've tested
a) a mixed USB-C Headphone from Logitech & everything seems to be as expected (seeing it block in the terminal, and looking for it the sound output it is not appearing as well) b) but on the test-phone (connected via USB-C cable -> USB-C laptop input), I can see it in the file manager appear, even before having given it any unblock via usbguard-add device xyz <-> I assume this is just cosmetic?

pixel1-blocked

State:

17: block id 18d1:4ee1 serial "strippedXYZ" name "Pixel 6 Pro" hash "strippedXYZ" parent-hash "strippedXYZ" via-port "3-4" with-interface 06:01:01 with-connect-type "hotplug"
  • Maybe this is just cosmetic, are there any paths /ways I could check?
  • Even when going on the phone on "USB Preferences -> File transfer" I cannot access the data, so USBGuard appears to be working
    • Also sharing internet does not appear to work via "USB tethering"
    • Not sure if this is worth to mention: The phone is getting charged via the bus?
  • Still the question remains, why it is showing up on devices?

Thanks

pdolinic avatar Dec 24 '22 11:12 pdolinic

could it be you do see the device show up but you cannot browse the filesystem(s) ? i think that's what I've seen before and should be 'normal behavior'

JLT032 avatar Nov 25 '23 21:11 JLT032