extensions icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
extensions copied to clipboard

cursor: translate cursor menu

Open SharkPool-SP opened this issue 10 months ago • 13 comments

Resolves: https://github.com/TurboWarp/extensions/issues/1987

I changed some naming or cursors, lmk if some others should be changed as well...

SharkPool-SP avatar Apr 09 '25 17:04 SharkPool-SP

If you are going to do this preferably add an index for each item like native scratch, so people who dont know english (or the right value cause you changed the naming) can still use the block effectively.

that or we need to make a new block and use a field instead

done

SharkPool-SP avatar Apr 10 '25 03:04 SharkPool-SP

!format

SharkPool-SP avatar Apr 10 '25 03:04 SharkPool-SP

The formatting bot didn't find any formatting issues. It currently only checks the extensions folder. The author or a maintainer can run terminal command 'npm run format' manually to format all files.

github-actions[bot] avatar Apr 10 '25 03:04 github-actions[bot]

GarboMuffin in #1987:

if the names don't match the internal CSS names anymore, a lot of them could have much better names

The current names are meant to parody those used in the CSS "cursor" attribute. These names are not localized to any language except English, and so there's not really a reason to translate them unless we plan to change the names to make them more descriptive. I don't see anything wrong with doing so.

NexusKitten avatar Apr 10 '25 03:04 NexusKitten

before doing that, as their is obviously conflicting opinions, can you consult with the other people...

yuri-kiss avatar May 21 '25 04:05 yuri-kiss

before doing that, as their is obviously conflicting opinions, can you consult with the other people...

im fine with no numbers

SharkPool-SP avatar May 21 '25 04:05 SharkPool-SP

before doing that, as their is obviously conflicting opinions, can you consult with the other people...

im fine with no numbers

that isnt the point. there are other reviewers on this team besides just you and garbomuffin... and this is already a precedence set by scratchfoundation for their translated accept reporters menus.. which this so keenly breaks on purpose now; with no consultation to anyone else before hand in which the PR is involved.

yuri-kiss avatar May 21 '25 04:05 yuri-kiss

before doing that, as their is obviously conflicting opinions, can you consult with the other people...

im fine with no numbers

that isnt the point. there are other reviewers on this team besides just you and garbomuffin... and this is already a precedence set by scratchfoundation for their translated accept reporters menus.. which this so keenly breaks on purpose now; with no consultation to anyone else before hand in which the PR is involved.

No other reviewers voiced a concern for numbers. Additionally, no other extension in the TW gallery follows that number format.

Sure get the other's opinions, but there doesnt seem to be a point

SharkPool-SP avatar May 21 '25 04:05 SharkPool-SP

before doing that, as their is obviously conflicting opinions, can you consult with the other people...

im fine with no numbers

that isnt the point. there are other reviewers on this team besides just you and garbomuffin... and this is already a precedence set by scratchfoundation for their translated accept reporters menus.. which this so keenly breaks on purpose now; with no consultation to anyone else before hand in which the PR is involved.

No other reviewers voiced a concern for numbers. Additionally, no other extension in the TW gallery follows that number format.

Sure get the other's opinions, but there doesnt seem to be a point

Additionally, no other extension in the TW gallery follows that number format.

"this is already a precedence set by scratchfoundation" "breaks on purpose now"

there is a point, you are choosing to ignore it. https://github.com/TurboWarp/extensions/pull/2076#discussion_r2048179943 https://github.com/TurboWarp/extensions/pull/2076#pullrequestreview-2755039521

further talk on this subject was done in the discord: https://discord.com/channels/837024174865776680/1147654296926687242/1321630894204649502 https://discord.com/channels/837024174865776680/1147654296926687242/1321634779040448512 https://discord.com/channels/837024174865776680/1147654296926687242/1321637065439580202

yuri-kiss avatar May 21 '25 04:05 yuri-kiss

We already have many extensions that have translatable menus without a number fallback or equivalent: Animated Text (when enabling features incompatible with Scratch Lab), Files, Pointer lock, Runtime options, Text, Clipping and blending, Iframe, Pen+ V7, Skins, Sensing+, Key simulation, Mobile keyboard, I stopped looking but there are lots more

Merging this without numbers also does not preclude the future possibility of adding numbers

GarboMuffin avatar May 21 '25 05:05 GarboMuffin

Feel free to revert my commit and make the numbers actually work though. I'll approve that

GarboMuffin avatar May 21 '25 05:05 GarboMuffin

!format

yuri-kiss avatar May 21 '25 05:05 yuri-kiss

So was this going to be merged or were we going to address the indexed items translation issue that doesn't seem to me like an actual issue

Brackets-Coder avatar Sep 13 '25 00:09 Brackets-Coder