Hacktoberfest icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Hacktoberfest copied to clipboard

Add points for people submitting code reviews?

Open earlduque opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

Maintainers already get points for either closing a pull request or merging them in, and this has historically been enough because most of time a pull review is only ever looked at by one maintainer.

But should we make it so reviews also get a point for situations like #32 where a bunch of reviewers submitted a review? Having a point for submitting review would solve this situation of reviewers-that-aren't-the-closer/merger get credit, but then our normal reviewer-and-closer/merger situation means people will be doubling up on maintainer points.

earlduque avatar Oct 11 '24 05:10 earlduque

Sounds good to me

wiz0floyd avatar Oct 11 '24 12:10 wiz0floyd

In prinicple sounds good to me too, but I am concerned this would be used to "game" the leaderboard. By default, anyone can add reviews, so one could just approve "everything everywhere all at once" without any substance to it.

Lacah avatar Nov 01 '24 19:11 Lacah