Binary icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Binary copied to clipboard

Provide information about binaries and their usage

Open ghost opened this issue 5 years ago • 3 comments

Could you make it a bit more transparent, what these binaries are and where/why they are needed in the first place?

Thanks!

ghost avatar Apr 03 '20 09:04 ghost

Scoops mirror for binaries that are no longer available

niheaven avatar Apr 03 '20 09:04 niheaven

Yeah, I saw that hint. The emphasis is on a) providing information about the binaries and their purpose b) in which context they are used / which programs do need them in their installation routine - maybe the title was a bit misleading.

For example, I wondered, why python installation via scoop included binary "dark". There is no README, URL or similar provided in the repo to clarify its usage. Given all these binaries in principle are a bunch of opaque .exe files, whose origin and intent is not clear, a bit more transparency would certainly make safety-conscious users more confident.

ghost avatar Apr 03 '20 11:04 ghost

dark is provided by the https://wixtoolset.org/. Scoop requires it as an unpacker for some programs (like python) but the complete package is too big. So we extracted it and just distribute it this way.

All other programs in this repo are just mirrored because they don't have any official download and/or the webpage is down.

Adding READMEs for every program sounds like a good idea. 👍

r15ch13 avatar Apr 03 '20 13:04 r15ch13