PathOfBuilding icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
PathOfBuilding copied to clipboard

Some scaling support missing for Siegebreaker / Replica Siegebreaker damaging ground

Open GustaveTheProud opened this issue 2 years ago • 4 comments

Check version

  • [X] I'm running the latest version of Path of Building and I've verified this by checking the changelog

Check for duplicates

  • [X] I've checked for duplicate issues by using the search function of the issue tracker

Check for support

  • [X] I've checked that the calculation is supposed to be supported. If it isn't please open a feature request instead (Red text is a feature request).

What is the value from the calculation ingame?

Using low life to make my mirror arrow's clone detonate on summon, I tried the interaction of caustic ground from siegebreaker with support such as "Void Manipulation" and "Efficacy". I used the area lunaris concourse from Act 8 on the named monster "Nightbringer Lucius". When using such support the caustic ground is able to deal around 75% of his life but around 50% without them.

Those supports seem to affect the caustic ground created from the belt (making it similar to other burning ground effect such as flame dash)

What is the value from the calculation in Path of Building?

Path of Building doesn't register such support as "impacting" the damaging ground. (it does scale from minion damage / minion life and thing such as Predator support though). I suppose it's missing tags related to damage over time and chaos (siegebreaker) / fire (replica siegebreaker), duration most likely too.

How to reproduce the issue

  • Put any minion as a base skill
  • Equip siegrebreaker or it's replica variant
  • Add support to the minion gem such as combustion / efficacy / void manipulation / burning damage support.
  • None of those impact the damaging ground but they do seem to work in game (don't have access to replica siegebreaker but I don't see any reason for it's behaviour to not follow the caustic ground of classic siegebreaker)

Character build code

eNrdHNtu27jyufkKwUCBXZxNHN-SNHB2kWtjIG69dtqefSpoibbZUKIrUkndRf_9DEnJlm1Rpix1D7B92HXEuXNmODOi3f3jm0-dZxxywoKLWuPouObgwGUeCaYXtQ-Pd4dntT9-P-gOkJi9n1xFhMqV3w9eddVnh-JnTC9qbwBNoHCKxceEVOszPJujQMwwC_roCwvfMu-i9o4FuOaMUeARkfzlUsT5O-Tji9rIBeSag7iLA-969VwD-ogEI-Y-YfE2ZNEc5K05zwS_9JkHML3-4P3wMcWUBGmmIPSr7oCiBQ5HAgmHw38uapeuIM8YQIHvA_GJAIqIRkDutFY3oIC50BTfp2CPd8BeRSEXN8iHj7txRnOMvSVY0wQ2CPHtZIKV_NchEdczFLgW5IvC9iMqyJwSHC7hG0cdE8b9FvHGsZH8IxOI3gxGuwXRkMzC4p-ImF1RsKAVXQndmwZEYGvwASOcBYWktgK-jiiF2LKDZf6YBJY69lGArhlf2e7NmzzQAQ4h-MQaxvEOhBF2GcRrGqXx5syCSzaukd0DmWB7yEKaxAhFpdlPj9uRLVxhwvsJNITMZAc5Eqs80DHTw1_TgKdGwBv8bZXq8silAc3keoGwI5cGbHQ6ZvGemVBHklWs394PVlSbrbYxd88WnLiI9tE34kc-JM1H9IQDK9wHMp2JADKFCfn0tGHCvSMh3gPtmlFvH7QZYtyEd3bWyIsrK1PASemeS-he4NqF64cgxByHz6kDNt_WEzyEMJKn-Jhia5wVmzgcbU5DzWyKg5jjwk6lB4zd2VuojIZIYLuMvQrgs3zbSmAr20rADNvm0F_HKGAmiZhtpsbxUTMPq6ClbgMcThejGcHUKwadSHaN5lblnnuexrYy-Dq7Qk6TRi1okk8o9OwOk6IyPSOeTrONk3xzaXA718RQDQKCh22r3kHIvsi6mhZDuwx9FoWWG66BrRRIDgvdPwyxF7l2R9IVhV7JVnqQitJCGJdCIPfphnlTXIhJcYxRNJ9DppBbbosnT7oh5iRV0hyeWEC_B3-1Clt5JtozWEFbM1ie8_ZcNlDsdZEH9Sabtg24NYtlq9qHjOBDqlddLjTuq5A3bg40RlaNjgK07LYG7AUkn8mZBS8GDQXNEqFlFCXEwfeFNf01cCsGt4EXhTIUrHlsYlix2T0e0WvbIw_DtGMLfH3a0SgJZpwoGCAzJgpbkLLpN7hVJqxx-pAJbZ4-ZIKbpw9GDdPAnXbjqNU0YeSMILZhM0YQ-dTXy_rT1mkeYH79kImSX8tsoeSWd7nQBWWzr7ceiQ_FCuc3SCCHYxS6swdIshe1WuqvO0TpGA5eeCqxunU1iZWfev6chUI9vEbU5YpmL5hHwgnUFNUn3P08jiYTOTAFmiJUY97bu7vb68fex9tYjDQKfyKUfg4ifyznf_r_q_gbYVWKODwac_3xovaR4JeRxLrBAhEKmclllKI5x95FbYIoB84EPiqYEejrihxqCgqaxySdZNNaAZgp3X7DoQB9oYZ1Q4KNci3XdwilGUofkNtmoiYzjJmQLqGuERfaHwyWUrnPTEVOaY3qyMUcXPAZRI2c49UdlhCLOeZQ1JIJcaXf52_5I0BrqBy7uC6cVe4iZ7_jQtBMQ6VhEwG9aEbWadaEHa_mWFUldaNV9aoZ_Qa7yKi7XjQjL1MMC9QrimwqS6gcSu_goJFODkFzSags2ow7e0vxEsRM8L2Y4VBXgkZKfchRCUhu4IRkHAlzGKcgcmyljiSDheSaGVXPUQw6yLWcTLR28hgMmoYxk9INuTGR5aEOc_LpMD-VJp2uwfJ6NUf_pNk3qB4v54iueg_j1sedTF5qgDbXnBrkohlZh9Y2CRFGlhRUGNzgCYYElhsHS5icBCyi4AZypcgxqCUpfaBdPjPi6R67FDWlZDaxlaUK0dL5JdNuhSmqGURZ02-MJioxfzwkN6T-FMgOQpCz73OqAjtKy6b9HiMqew9GyxHcehlQSk8mOAq8G1mNl1RUFvPRHIglkr3PKutWXrZJtVtPCu6uqnG4w6ESf4t9frWABulOZvGNlgkpw8ZFsFBXGdZwEnYenqCIyud_RogSsZDtQurpg76BEbDQX75PAlIz9iJdU1OUJReHxPzwoFcuqYiJSXaJvbR1YoGUmg31LH6obl9crqRWGiu5SeDSyMO9IJ7UgDQEHIWisZRMXiiRL0-WBtygs2TzqgvSxMBvKRsj2kxQVBcSN1brvFMr8cMhIrBboyfoLIQMyviKSvO4tka7sUa7J6vTyPclfY3It7nKyxjOV224nqrE1CbEgAMU6m2cYl-u9qH98aCRq_cEGLkuLV1XZODTFquvqb3dMNeS-EppcNZA85JNmpwnJ9I72eJvWaW-y-IFrKa8LBkRyXoqy0R5Rln6aQaRLItkqa9RnVXRVr1ySQuasqvUIoneco6xYYOE135WyJA0cRDsDTGa4_BnGemOuRGX4_SfbacbjMTMR-FTYSMNQgxkWfgP26cXuCFGEIRXUShn9P-MO5m4FrRZjP3_8SwoQ4irpgF7Z5YtEraKLxEr10oPMB5ZMivYWzcDIVsNZVUScUF-xqnwEcp_aIbJPKJxh7K3lkZStnpKAs4aBa1uV5_KqvqpJ-WPqul0KSc_PoYYJxWbItaIqyX4I31ZVapxLCscLnC4iMcYsgQKmCcrsM7ZWatVcwSQS12UleZ0V-haqg_DB70bMyHm_Lxef3l5OZpDzmMT_I1QfOQyvz4HJJDpUNn9UJKtX8K_q-ml-qfVSyh19dVZXo9VBdmVmlI5-eEdE1jNjOXD5A-luhzpxhPokQilPt8Z8_9Susp6EtoD0UfzuO6Ta3FV2oorUYHEDQFrhKoJSnZJAv43mX531a7HRk4nwohjfZPtE6QXKJrkY8lHj6oBMF2qDlEILnHufHjX-_PD7cGIQHMwhgT4hMMDkPJ54VxhKg6UeEP89dxptw96_pwSF5qlc6dx8LdAU37-Bb9Abwdb-BklY6Qff4comOLz46POj__80uwctjq_OoI5YBAcTMVsC9OTLR9fw_vl5LBx_OtrWTDrpAyeogp2R497HD3viUlRqGXssGXVEyO58t3sbyspQjULkQliXYHG6WGzBcRAA_U61xkuAQ90XufODD1jp_PacVWCkaCPCOLKgQoD-iTnhYiZoyfY_OAvFoVOgsihJUaec41kXnEdeVk78CSaOrR_g-4FyfdMTvP4tcMmDnT3JFxTBmIqFksfOA6cK-CA0guUJ_eZN5TKOEolcKGjTi12gziojRDNnRCtnRDtnRCdnRDJBReV7dZ9uZnpy0Ms3RQ5Zp9G0wifO_cY9vFf7OEWvt05bHa0b8tKNO3aWW6a1Db7uanisO2lWlakouOHOaD6iCjT-ATzzLj6V3u7nDOY0vv6AIIy4UBx4w_GcJqpA1W9ndQ4TmP0gubO5XjBOaKOPuYcyVnoyuI4kW8XnU0azT1oFEC5YkzwKuTO0r-I7DKBlMG_g-rlyWkVl7yZJXmrgp3bw4rNn0GjXYEuJxXIcVLR3pR27yKbe4-pj0UpETIc-6S0BEVCAzqkZ_m2oiTLVkVZoVFaknYF3tioICraBd1gBd6w27NSDLNcvwrLFc_KnbJilz1IWoUE8BaOfoFcxmeyN7C873dKUyiefApveHlDdarZsWZZzzupIE20Kgi6VskIaFd0-JaNxEY1-9oq7JLtwhhlVa2qit7HfSra7ZOy4VPRdlflvXsdf5LQPllgT7yy-zBU84LSCbhZzc5VkT_3dKLSJmgVtXqjou1uV2P7TmkLFI7_iuK0iOSXfkQzShQ950neo6jJvrqVzoIJmW7dMccB9hcj8h0P5NdBxepieh97JPIzbqVv_sTHCkX91Ec9m0WPXzHOd8Ju_mjJTgT9ayaZYAOKXDxj1MPhmrL62yzJdfrT9Ldds-DlJe7k1WuC1LLASb4tl-B08lHWv2mYuu7ffNNO7jnFW9itb_4kzP8Af7WZag==

Screenshots

No response

GustaveTheProud avatar Mar 28 '23 23:03 GustaveTheProud

It seems this isn't implemented as burning ground when the other sources were implemented. This means it also has issues related to stacking burning ground. And probably is based off some various custom code somewhere.

QuickStick123 avatar Mar 28 '23 23:03 QuickStick123

Hello, Just wanted to add some other interactions.

The calculations also interact weirdly depending on the source of the damage increase. If I put a bow with implicit (synthetised) % increased ele damage, it does work in the calculation, same thing for the suffix % damage over time multiplier (using mirror or blink arrow clone as they use your bow and quiver).

Only support gems attached to the minion don't register using same increase / multiplier as the bow (elemental focus with its quality % increased ele damage or default multiplier on the gem or efficacy with its damage over time multiplier not registering)

GustaveTheProud avatar Mar 29 '23 08:03 GustaveTheProud

There is also this issue https://github.com/PathOfBuildingCommunity/PathOfBuilding/issues/5080.

QuickStick123 avatar Mar 29 '23 08:03 QuickStick123

Has any progress been made on this?

paulnirenberg avatar Mar 30 '24 21:03 paulnirenberg