OpenSprites-next icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
OpenSprites-next copied to clipboard

Do we need comments on profiles and resources?

Open jamesd-uk opened this issue 9 years ago • 8 comments

I'm wondering if this is a necessary feature. It means that we must implement a reporting/moderation toolbox for comments. OS accounts are tied to Scratch accounts which allow for commenting already. Thoughts?

jamesd-uk avatar Oct 24 '16 12:10 jamesd-uk

Disclaimer: I haven't worked on the project (especially design) for like a year.

Being able to work together on things, via comments on uploaded resources, would be great! That way people can review new sprites and music, talk about how a script could be more efficient, etc.

towerofnix avatar Oct 24 '16 12:10 towerofnix

I think we need a system for replies, too - to allow for discussion - basically like the forums.

bates64 avatar Oct 25 '16 07:10 bates64

It seems as if we are trying to create our own community, which seems a bit unnecessary since 100% of our user base shall already be part of one.

jamesd-uk avatar Oct 25 '16 15:10 jamesd-uk

Doesn't really matter whether or not people are part of a community. Say a bunch of people come from.. afterschool?.. to work on a project together - should they be able to discuss the project, or is that unnecessary? :)

towerofnix avatar Oct 25 '16 16:10 towerofnix

I agree, stifling discussion isn't what we want.

If we are creating spaces for discussion, we must ensure that staff have an effective toolbox for dealing with inappropriate comments.

jamesd-uk avatar Oct 25 '16 19:10 jamesd-uk

What about the ability to edit and delete comments?

Tymewalk avatar Oct 30 '16 16:10 Tymewalk

Scratch doesn't allow the editing and deleting of comments because inappropriate content can be removed before being reviewed. I think that applies here also.

jamesd-uk avatar Oct 30 '16 19:10 jamesd-uk

@The-Cheese-Eater it allows deletion for the owner(s) of the resource!

bates64 avatar Nov 04 '16 15:11 bates64