OpenDataStandards icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
OpenDataStandards copied to clipboard

Should 'OEDVersion' be a required field?

Open MattDonovan82 opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

Description

Should the OEDVersion field in all four OED input files be a 'required' field?

Reasons for change

Currently an optional field but making it 'Required' ensures a solid reference to the version of OED. Its' been discussed as a possibility and so I'm just putting it out there for the community to comment and get some feedback.

Scope of change

  • [X] Location File
  • [X] Accounts File
  • [X] Reinsurance Scope
  • [X] Reinsurance Info

Impact of change

This will be a breaking change for most validation exercises so it will go into OED v4.0.0 which is a major update.

Data type, default values, are blanks allowed, list valid values

Field Name Data type Default values Blanks allowed Valid values
Acc; Loc; ReinsInfo; ReinsScope Varcher(10) Latest version of OED No 4.0.0

MattDonovan82 avatar Jun 28 '24 14:06 MattDonovan82

Just to bring it to your attention @johcarter @benhayes21 @sstruzik @aiste-kalinauskaite

MattDonovan82 avatar Jun 28 '24 14:06 MattDonovan82

Further discussions suggest this should remain an 'optional' field as it will cause too much disruption to make it 'required' and it's not ideal to have this for every row of data in all four files. There was an idea to include this in the model settings file instead.

Any further comments @sstruzik @johcarter @benhayes21 ?

MattDonovan82 avatar Jul 12 '24 10:07 MattDonovan82