MathCAT icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
MathCAT copied to clipboard

What should be said for × and · in "LiteralSpeak" and character navigation mode?

Open NSoiffer opened this issue 1 year ago • 5 comments

There are many ways to speak these. Most come with some semantic baggage.

· is probably easiest: perhaps "center dot"

× can be "times", "cross", "cross product", "by". Something like "cross sign" seems too wordy.

There are other symbols that need a literal meaning, but this is a starting point and maybe some convention can be established.

Thoughts?

NSoiffer avatar Jan 05 '25 21:01 NSoiffer

One disadvantage of "times" for the × symbol is its lack of specificity; listeners could imagine a dot, a star/asterisk, or an X-shaped cross.

Though "times" is how NVDA verbalizes the Unicode symbol.

NV-Codes avatar Jan 06 '25 00:01 NV-Codes

FYI: the Unicode name for the symbol is "Multiplication Sign". I don't that is a great choice: it doubt everyone will think of the same symbol and the name is pretty long. But I suspect it is a little less ambiguous than "times".

NSoiffer avatar Jan 07 '25 19:01 NSoiffer

"Multiplication"is very verbose. My maths knowledge is much less than others here, but "times"means multiply to me. Could abbreviate to "mult", but people would need to know what it meant.

Andrew

andrew-l-d avatar Jan 07 '25 20:01 andrew-l-d

I'm currently leaning towards "cross". "cross sign" is less semantic, but rather long. I'm still looking for better ideas...

NSoiffer avatar Jan 13 '25 14:01 NSoiffer

Going once, going twice... Is everyone ok with "cross"?

NSoiffer avatar Jan 28 '25 00:01 NSoiffer