json_api_client icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
json_api_client copied to clipboard

Proposal to add coersion or proc types

Open AlexParamonov opened this issue 9 years ago • 6 comments

At the moment I use following patch to support custom coersion:

JsonApiClient::Schema::Property.prepend(
  Module.new do
    def cast(value)
      return super unless proc_coercion?
      type.call(value)
    end

    private

    def proc_coercion?
      type.is_a?(Proc)
    end
  end
)

Used as:

    property :names,        type: -> (data) { data.to_s.split('#,') }
    property :interval,     type: -> (data) { data[:begin]..data[:end]  }

Do you have any plans to have something similar?

AlexParamonov avatar Mar 24 '17 13:03 AlexParamonov

Would you be open to opening up a PR with an idea of how that would work?

gaorlov avatar Mar 20 '19 15:03 gaorlov

Hi @gaorlov, I don't work with JsonApiClient anymore. Code which does the job is all included in this particular issue. I used coercion mainly to create ruby range objects and arrays.

AlexParamonov avatar Mar 22 '19 09:03 AlexParamonov

@senid231 what do you think about a callable type? Have you seen people use the types much?

gaorlov avatar Mar 22 '19 17:03 gaorlov

@gaorlov If we talk about object with one method I've prefer call here. but we should keep backward compatibility - if object doesn't respond to call we should use cast instead

senid231 avatar Mar 24 '19 09:03 senid231

@senid231 I guess my question is more: does this belong in the client gem or is this a higher level concern? This feels like parser logic rather than a cast/field validation. Should this be a separate option? Like a

property :names, parser: (data) -> { data.to_s.split('#,') }

property :value, type: :double, parser: ValueParser

property :range, parser_name: "RangeParser"

Where the parcer classes look like

class Parser
  attr_reader :field

  def initialize( field )
     @field = field
  end
end

def ArrayParser < Parser
  def parse
    field.split( ", " )
  end
end

def RangeParser < Parser
  def parse
    start, end = field.split( "-to-" )
    ( start ... end )
  end
end

But again, I'm not sure if this belong in this gem. What do you think?

gaorlov avatar Mar 24 '19 15:03 gaorlov

@gaorlov I think we should keep it simple currently we have property which can be class with method cast we should keep that logic to not break code for people who already implementing types in this way we should extend property logic by allowing :type option to be any object that has method call after that we will be able do like this:

class OptionsType
  def self.call(value)
    OpenStruct.new(value) if value
  end
end

class Person < JsonApiClient::Resource
  property :names, type: ->(value) { value.split(',') }
  property :options, type: OptionsType
end

senid231 avatar Mar 24 '19 16:03 senid231