E2OpenPlugins
Concerns regarding CoPilot/AI suggestions and change requests
There has been a gamut of CoPilot-driven change requests in the last few hours alone.
Of particular concern is the sensibility of some suggestions, for example, directly modifying plugin code. One such example is Bootstrap Select: https://github.com/E2OpenPlugins/e2openplugin-OpenWebif/pull/1664
Such changes are likely to cause further trouble next time the libs are updated by dependabot, as the changes made will be undone.
At the very least, such changes should be suggested directly to the Bootstrap Select plugin developers.
Additionally, even a wet-behind-the-ears junior developer should know better than to directly modify plugin code.
This - in my opinion at least - calls into question the viability of AI-powered "suggestions". Granted, people might feel that they're contributing in some meaningful way to various projects, but without oversight and stringent testing, such changes could cause breakage or regression bugs further down the line, by which time, someone will have to waste their time manually fixing up various issues.
Can CoPilot be disabled on this project until such a point as someone can dedicate their time to thoroughly testing all of the changes on a running instance of Enigma2 before they're merged? I and others have put countless hours into thoroughly testing any and every change we've made to OpenWebif; I'd hate to see it destroyed by constant, unrelenting, untested "tweaks".
https://www.theregister.com/2025/07/16/if_you_want_a_picture/
Another one, directly and nonsensically changing a jQuery plugin's code
May I suggest rolling back any and all changes that have been made by this contributor, please, 'cos this is fast becoming a shitshow of random and quite possibly unneccessary changes. AI coding is the modern-day equivalent of asbestos.
Furthermore, allowing bots to make constant, unverified changes to code runs a SIGNIFICANT risk of malicious code being introduced, either in one fell swoop or piecemeal over a period of time, and quietly released to the wild.
Why are CoPilot/AI changes allowed to be merged without a requirement for peer review and approval?
The question outside of your criticism is where you see mistakes. Can you describe that in more detail?
@kueken , what is your experience with javascript? How many projects do you contribute to? Are you powered by AI?
Why are you directly modifying code in established js libraries and plugins?
Where is your constructive contribution? The plugin has not been serviced and you know that very well. Everything is going in the direction of the OE Alliance and will then be updated there. Where is your error message now, or what exactly are you denouncing here? OE-A also works with bots. This is everyday life
@kueken , have you tested these changes? If so,
- on which device make and model have you tested your changes?
- on which Enigma2 distro have you tested your changes?
- which version of said distro have you tested your changes on?
On behalf of all contributors to this project, I want you to hold yourself accountable for the changes you make.
So far you've only responded to every question with two questions of your own.
So, there are still a number of python bugs in there. I"ve left them for you now. I have extra Ruff currently deactivated, because it detects the errors, but also falke8 describes the errors exactly. You know where you can find them.
It would be nice if you could make your obvious time available for this.
whatever you want to tell me, unfortunately I don"t understand you. But yes, this plugin certainly still has a few construction sites.
https://github.com/E2OpenPlugins/e2openplugin-OpenWebif/issues/1635#issuecomment-1942767941