BriefFiniteElement.Net icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
BriefFiniteElement.Net copied to clipboard

Add GetInternalForce for TetrahedronElement

Open epsi1on opened this issue 3 years ago • 8 comments

Add GetInternalForce() For TetrahedronElement. Strain and stress are constant through tetrahedron element, Therefore simple to add this feature...

epsi1on avatar Jul 12 '22 14:07 epsi1on

continue from #140,

As you know the strain and stress in constant through a tetrahedron element, But as long as i see, in your output, the stress is not constant through tethrahedrons. Just thinking about the reason... Do you have any idea?

epsi1on avatar Jul 19 '22 15:07 epsi1on

As you know the strain and stress in constant through a tetrahedron element, But as long as i see, in your output, the stress is not constant through tethrahedrons. Just thinking about the reason... Do you have any idea?

Can we please continue discussion about tetra hedron internal force here: #142 (for future reference) Thanks

Could you send what do you see? Maybe I didnt send the nodes coordinate? And I sent a displacement, I hadnt sent a strain

SilberVogel avatar Jul 21 '22 10:07 SilberVogel

Could you send what do you see? Maybe I didnt send the nodes coordinate? And I sent a displacement, I hadnt sent a strain

I think you also sent some stresses. right? Let me put all files into the repository. then will continue... Thanks

epsi1on avatar Jul 23 '22 05:07 epsi1on

i did upload files into repository 804e225

here are the files: https://github.com/BriefFiniteElementNet/BriefFiniteElement.Net/tree/master/Validation/Validation/Case_03/output/Ansys%20output

epsi1on avatar Jul 23 '22 06:07 epsi1on

@SilberVogel I think we need stress inside each element. Currently stresses are evaluated at each node. and each node is common between several elements, so the internal force of each element is not clear.. Thanks

epsi1on avatar Jul 24 '22 06:07 epsi1on

@SilberVogel I think we need stress inside each element. Currently stresses are evaluated at each node. and each node is common between several elements, so the internal force of each element is not clear.. Thanks

Cant find correct comand at ANSYS for actual requirements. Will try it more and after send you results.

SilberVogel avatar Jul 25 '22 09:07 SilberVogel

@SilberVogel I think we need stress inside each element. Currently stresses are evaluated at each node. and each node is common between several elements, so the internal force of each element is not clear.. Thanks

@epsi1on hope this will helpful Case 3 element_stress.zip It contains Principal`s of Stress in [MPa] for each element and they need to be approximated.

SilberVogel avatar Jul 27 '22 13:07 SilberVogel

@SilberVogel I think we need stress inside each element. Currently stresses are evaluated at each node. and each node is common between several elements, so the internal force of each element is not clear.. Thanks

@epsi1on hope this will helpful Case 3 element_stress.zip It contains Principal`s of Stress in [MPa] for each element and they need to be approximated.

Very good, I think this is just right thing...! let me check. thank you

epsi1on avatar Jul 28 '22 11:07 epsi1on