azure-powershell icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
azure-powershell copied to clipboard
verified publisher icon Azure

Get-AzAdvisorRecommendation returning no VM specific recommendations anymore

Open mrdenny opened this issue 2 years ago • 1 comments

Description

I’ve got a PowerShell script that uses Get-AzAdvisorRecommendation to pull down the list of recommendations from Azure Advisor. It used to have a bunch of recommendations in the ExtendedProperties value.

From conversations with the PG, this isn't expected.

Issue script & Debug output

PS C:\Users\denny> $DebugPreference = 'continue'
PS C:\Users\denny> Get-AzAdvisorRecommendation
DEBUG: 2:15:59 PM - GetAzureRMContextCommand begin processing with ParameterSet 'GetSingleContext'.
DEBUG: 2:15:59 PM - [ConfigManager] Got nothing from [DisplayBreakingChangeWarning], Module = [], Cmdlet = [].
Returning default value [True].
DEBUG: 2:15:59 PM - [ConfigManager] Got nothing from [DisplayRegionIdentified], Module = [], Cmdlet = []. Returning
default value [True].
DEBUG: 2:15:59 PM - [ConfigManager] Got nothing from [CheckForUpgrade], Module = [], Cmdlet = []. Returning default
value [False].
DEBUG: 2:15:59 PM - GetAzureRMContextCommand end processing.
DEBUG: [CmdletBeginProcessing]: Starting command
DEBUG: CmdletBeginProcessing:
DEBUG: CmdletProcessRecordStart:
DEBUG: CmdletGetPipeline:
DEBUG: CmdletBeforeAPICall:
DEBUG: URLCreated:
/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations?api-version=2020-01-01
DEBUG: RequestCreated:
/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations?api-version=2020-01-01
DEBUG: HeaderParametersAdded:
DEBUG: 2:15:59 PM - [ConfigManager] Got nothing from [EnableLoginByWam], Module = [], Cmdlet = []. Returning default
value [False].
DEBUG: ============================ HTTP REQUEST ============================

HTTP Method:
GET

Absolute Uri:
https://management.azure.com/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendat
ions?api-version=2020-01-01

Headers:
x-ms-unique-id                : 1
x-ms-client-request-id        : fff6b971-9624-4c23-b76b-0db028f9a17f
CommandName                   : .
FullCommandName               : Get-AzAdvisorRecommendation_List
ParameterSetName              : __AllParameterSets
User-Agent                    : AzurePowershell/v0.0.0,PSVersion/v5.1.22621.2506,Az.Advisor/2.0.0

Body:


DEBUG: BeforeCall:
DEBUG: ============================ HTTP RESPONSE ============================

Status Code:
OK

Headers:
Pragma                        : no-cache
Strict-Transport-Security     : max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains
X-Content-Type-Options        : nosniff
x-ms-throttling-version       : v1
x-ms-ratelimit-remaining-subscription-resource-requests: 599
x-ms-request-id               : 69a2b5f5-aca3-4427-aea2-1aaa46317428
x-ms-correlation-request-id   : 69a2b5f5-aca3-4427-aea2-1aaa46317428
x-ms-routing-request-id       : NORTHCENTRALUS:20240429T211558Z:69a2b5f5-aca3-4427-aea2-1aaa46317428
X-Cache                       : CONFIG_NOCACHE
X-MSEdge-Ref                  : Ref A: 7FB134680DD34BF5B5E10925F937D753 Ref B: CH1AA2020616047 Ref C:
2024-04-29T21:15:58Z
Cache-Control                 : no-cache
Date                          : Mon, 29 Apr 2024 21:15:58 GMT

Body:
{
  "value": [
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "High",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.COMPUTE/VIRTUALMACHINES",
        "impactedValue": "TestBuildAgent",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T20:11:11.6056989Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "066a047a-9ace-45f4-ac50-6325840a6b00",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Use Availability zones for better resiliency and availability",
          "solution": "Use Availability zones for better resiliency and availability"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "Location": "centralus",
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/Portal-Test/providers/Microsoft.Compute/virtualMach
ines/TestBuildAgent"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/Portal-Test/providers/Microsoft.Compute/virtualMach
ines/TestBuildAgent/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/d4da4e87-8422-e056-ae75-b1a982d42c9d",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "d4da4e87-8422-e056-ae75-b1a982d42c9d"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "High",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Subscriptions/subscriptions",
        "impactedValue": "ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T17:04:51.3591082Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "242639fd-cd73-4be2-8f55-70478db8d1a5",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Create an Azure Service Health alert",
          "solution": "Create an Azure Service Health alert"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "MonitoringAndAlerting",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId": "/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/2d3722aa-885b-6aa7-5b3
5-82521021b875",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "2d3722aa-885b-6aa7-5b35-82521021b875"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "High",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.SQL/SERVERS/DATABASES",
        "impactedValue": "CspPortalTest",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T07:42:09.8851054Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "807e58d0-e385-41ad-987b-4a4b3e3fb563",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable zone redundancy for Azure SQL Database to achieve high availability and resiliency.",
          "solution": "Enable zone redundancy for Azure SQL Database to achieve high availability and resiliency."
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/EE3CB3C0-3415-43EE-8E63-A0170716EE9E/resourceGroups/SQLDB-Development/providers/microsoft.sql/servers/d
cac-dev/databases/CspPortalTest"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/EE3CB3C0-3415-43EE-8E63-A0170716EE9E/resourceGroups/SQLDB-Development/providers/microsoft.sql/servers/d
cac-dev/databases/CspPortalTest/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/c0cd5570-0bb3-8d0c-b3d9-10808a764cf7",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "c0cd5570-0bb3-8d0c-b3d9-10808a764cf7"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "High",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.SQL/SERVERS/DATABASES",
        "impactedValue": "AzureAssessments",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T07:42:09.8851054Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "807e58d0-e385-41ad-987b-4a4b3e3fb563",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable zone redundancy for Azure SQL Database to achieve high availability and resiliency.",
          "solution": "Enable zone redundancy for Azure SQL Database to achieve high availability and resiliency."
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/EE3CB3C0-3415-43EE-8E63-A0170716EE9E/resourceGroups/SQLDB-Development/providers/microsoft.sql/servers/d
cac-dev/databases/AzureAssessments"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/EE3CB3C0-3415-43EE-8E63-A0170716EE9E/resourceGroups/SQLDB-Development/providers/microsoft.sql/servers/d
cac-dev/databases/AzureAssessments/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/732ee856-6f2f-fdfa-67e1-6ee3417cde07",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "732ee856-6f2f-fdfa-67e1-6ee3417cde07"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "High",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Network/trafficmanagerprofiles",
        "impactedValue": "portal-dev-dcac-com",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T16:57:28.9143943Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "0bbe0a49-3c63-49d3-ab4a-aa24198f03f7",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Add an endpoint configured to \"All (World)\"",
          "solution": "Add an endpoint configured to \"All (World)\""
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/portal-development/providers/Microsoft.Network/traf
ficmanagerprofiles/portal-dev-dcac-com"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/portal-development/providers/Microsoft.Network/traf
ficmanagerprofiles/portal-dev-dcac-com/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/ca496043-d532-92dd-3b1e-2ac29ab31e00
",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "ca496043-d532-92dd-3b1e-2ac29ab31e00"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "High",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Network/trafficmanagerprofiles",
        "impactedValue": "portal-test-dcac-com",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T16:57:28.9143943Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "0bbe0a49-3c63-49d3-ab4a-aa24198f03f7",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Add an endpoint configured to \"All (World)\"",
          "solution": "Add an endpoint configured to \"All (World)\""
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/portal-test/providers/Microsoft.Network/trafficmana
gerprofiles/portal-test-dcac-com"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/portal-test/providers/Microsoft.Network/trafficmana
gerprofiles/portal-test-dcac-com/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/57fcb660-9c80-cb7c-8a6d-267f06765001",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "57fcb660-9c80-cb7c-8a6d-267f06765001"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.NETWORK/VIRTUALNETWORKS",
        "impactedValue": "uscentral-development",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T11:30:24.6815021Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "56f0c458-521d-4b8b-a704-c0a099483d19",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity",
          "solution": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "region": "centralus",
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/networking/providers/microsoft.network/virtualnetwo
rks/uscentral-development"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/networking/providers/microsoft.network/virtualnetwo
rks/uscentral-development/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/42f49abf-587b-f07e-5f39-0a426d9b5c41",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "42f49abf-587b-f07e-5f39-0a426d9b5c41"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.NETWORK/VIRTUALNETWORKS",
        "impactedValue": "sqlplayground-vnet",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T11:30:24.6815021Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "56f0c458-521d-4b8b-a704-c0a099483d19",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity",
          "solution": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "region": "eastus",
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/sqlplayground/providers/microsoft.network/virtualne
tworks/sqlplayground-vnet"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/sqlplayground/providers/microsoft.network/virtualne
tworks/sqlplayground-vnet/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/46a3ac73-9ff3-c2ed-9a1c-5200883144af",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "46a3ac73-9ff3-c2ed-9a1c-5200883144af"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.NETWORK/VIRTUALNETWORKS",
        "impactedValue": "vhc01-vnet",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T11:30:24.6815021Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "56f0c458-521d-4b8b-a704-c0a099483d19",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity",
          "solution": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "region": "eastus2",
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/clientthings/providers/microsoft.network/virtualnet
works/vhc01-vnet"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/clientthings/providers/microsoft.network/virtualnet
works/vhc01-vnet/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/f79f9cd7-743d-76b3-b357-ccf573477ba9",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "f79f9cd7-743d-76b3-b357-ccf573477ba9"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.NETWORK/VIRTUALNETWORKS",
        "impactedValue": "development-northeurope",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T11:30:24.6815021Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "56f0c458-521d-4b8b-a704-c0a099483d19",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity",
          "solution": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "region": "northeurope",
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/networking/providers/microsoft.network/virtualnetwo
rks/development-northeurope"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/networking/providers/microsoft.network/virtualnetwo
rks/development-northeurope/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/85024293-5555-12fb-b0ef-712c97db49fe",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "85024293-5555-12fb-b0ef-712c97db49fe"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.NETWORK/VIRTUALNETWORKS",
        "impactedValue": "vnet-yukipractice",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T11:30:24.6815021Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "56f0c458-521d-4b8b-a704-c0a099483d19",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity",
          "solution": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "region": "eastus",
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/yukipractice/providers/microsoft.network/virtualnet
works/vnet-yukipractice"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/yukipractice/providers/microsoft.network/virtualnet
works/vnet-yukipractice/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/73494c3e-3169-193b-a414-2a7b85f41ae9",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "73494c3e-3169-193b-a414-2a7b85f41ae9"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.NETWORK/VIRTUALNETWORKS",
        "impactedValue": "uswest-dev-test-lab",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T11:30:24.6815021Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "56f0c458-521d-4b8b-a704-c0a099483d19",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity",
          "solution": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "region": "westus",
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/west-proviewpoc/providers/microsoft.network/virtual
networks/uswest-dev-test-lab"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/west-proviewpoc/providers/microsoft.network/virtual
networks/uswest-dev-test-lab/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/5dd416c4-49c3-c0a1-1ef8-2fda306ad21f",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "5dd416c4-49c3-c0a1-1ef8-2fda306ad21f"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.NETWORK/VIRTUALNETWORKS",
        "impactedValue": "sqlplaygroundvnet366",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T11:30:24.6815021Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "56f0c458-521d-4b8b-a704-c0a099483d19",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity",
          "solution": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "region": "germanywestcentral",
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/sqlplayground/providers/microsoft.network/virtualne
tworks/sqlplaygroundvnet366"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/sqlplayground/providers/microsoft.network/virtualne
tworks/sqlplaygroundvnet366/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/7338755f-2a5d-9791-e3d2-5b206c07db52",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "7338755f-2a5d-9791-e3d2-5b206c07db52"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.NETWORK/VIRTUALNETWORKS",
        "impactedValue": "vnet-ohmanagedinstance",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T11:30:24.6815021Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "56f0c458-521d-4b8b-a704-c0a099483d19",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity",
          "solution": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "region": "eastus",
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/ohdemo/providers/microsoft.network/virtualnetworks/
vnet-ohmanagedinstance"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/ohdemo/providers/microsoft.network/virtualnetworks/
vnet-ohmanagedinstance/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/110aaff8-aa87-596f-d508-dcbe7b0e2a84",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "110aaff8-aa87-596f-d508-dcbe7b0e2a84"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.NETWORK/VIRTUALNETWORKS",
        "impactedValue": "workers-vnet",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T11:30:24.6815021Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "56f0c458-521d-4b8b-a704-c0a099483d19",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity",
          "solution": "Use NAT gateway for outbound connectivity"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "region": "westus",
          "recommendationControl": "HighAvailability",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/ncsbndbxmanaged/providers/microsoft.network/virtual
networks/workers-vnet"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/ncsbndbxmanaged/providers/microsoft.network/virtual
networks/workers-vnet/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/7d14631c-2520-d09d-95df-abf357735e0e",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "7d14631c-2520-d09d-95df-abf357735e0e"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "MICROSOFT.COMPUTE/VIRTUALMACHINES",
        "impactedValue": "testbuildagent",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T06:16:54.4075795Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "651c7925-17a3-42e5-85cd-73bd095cf27f",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable Backups on your Virtual Machines",
          "solution": "Enable Backups on your Virtual Machines"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "isSQLIaaSExtensionPresent": "false",
          "isWindowsVm": "true",
          "vmLocation": "centralus",
          "recommendationControl": "DisasterRecovery",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/portal-test/providers/microsoft.compute/virtualmach
ines/testbuildagent"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourcegroups/portal-test/providers/microsoft.compute/virtualmach
ines/testbuildagent/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/add5801e-9218-206f-0898-540e37f42b59",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "add5801e-9218-206f-0898-540e37f42b59"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Storage/storageAccounts",
        "impactedValue": "hfdevops",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T20:32:26.418573Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "42dbf883-9e4b-4f84-9da4-232b87c4b5e9",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data",
          "solution": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data"
        },
        "suppressionIds": [
          "a84509f4-382e-4f27-e47a-4e2255a80428"
        ],
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/HF-Devops/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAccoun
ts/hfdevops"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/HF-Devops/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAccoun
ts/hfdevops/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/c03e7795-d86f-aaff-76a1-66557a4b83f0",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "c03e7795-d86f-aaff-76a1-66557a4b83f0"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Storage/storageAccounts",
        "impactedValue": "dbstoragemzfwd5mqdt2na",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T20:32:26.418573Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "42dbf883-9e4b-4f84-9da4-232b87c4b5e9",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data",
          "solution": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/NCSBNDBxManaged/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storage
Accounts/dbstoragemzfwd5mqdt2na"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/NCSBNDBxManaged/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storage
Accounts/dbstoragemzfwd5mqdt2na/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/c6821dc7-044c-0a0f-01c9-9e2d6b34fb9d",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "c6821dc7-044c-0a0f-01c9-9e2d6b34fb9d"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Storage/storageAccounts",
        "impactedValue": "databasebackpacks",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T20:32:26.418573Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "42dbf883-9e4b-4f84-9da4-232b87c4b5e9",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data",
          "solution": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data"
        },
        "suppressionIds": [
          "49bb509c-bf98-c9ae-f935-9ff671a16ff3"
        ],
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLDB-Demo/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAccou
nts/databasebackpacks"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLDB-Demo/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAccou
nts/databasebackpacks/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/ab92dc41-d482-5e22-23b1-ff3fe12ca59c",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "ab92dc41-d482-5e22-23b1-ff3fe12ca59c"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Storage/storageAccounts",
        "impactedValue": "dcacaudit",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T20:32:26.418573Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "42dbf883-9e4b-4f84-9da4-232b87c4b5e9",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data",
          "solution": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data"
        },
        "suppressionIds": [
          "1ae6265c-6214-7765-4405-b8bd4273bd29"
        ],
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLDB-Demo/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAccou
nts/dcacaudit"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLDB-Demo/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAccou
nts/dcacaudit/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/f5f5dfc6-0e0c-d77f-8cc1-5dc67e7b3bf1",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "f5f5dfc6-0e0c-d77f-8cc1-5dc67e7b3bf1"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Storage/storageAccounts",
        "impactedValue": "dcackeyvaultstorage",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T20:32:26.418573Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "42dbf883-9e4b-4f84-9da4-232b87c4b5e9",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data",
          "solution": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data"
        },
        "suppressionIds": [
          "fd6527b6-7147-0cd6-53f7-babf3eff0388"
        ],
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLDB-Development/providers/Microsoft.Storage/stora
geAccounts/dcackeyvaultstorage"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLDB-Development/providers/Microsoft.Storage/stora
geAccounts/dcackeyvaultstorage/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/05086b53-cbdc-34c4-65c0-c7bd0f39be9e",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "05086b53-cbdc-34c4-65c0-c7bd0f39be9e"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Storage/storageAccounts",
        "impactedValue": "sqlplayground99c6",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T20:32:26.418573Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "42dbf883-9e4b-4f84-9da4-232b87c4b5e9",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data",
          "solution": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLPlayground/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAc
counts/sqlplayground99c6"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLPlayground/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAc
counts/sqlplayground99c6/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/38d12bee-0b42-ae07-2a9e-9935d07be86e",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "38d12bee-0b42-ae07-2a9e-9935d07be86e"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Storage/storageAccounts",
        "impactedValue": "sqlplaygrounddiag645",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T20:32:26.418573Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "42dbf883-9e4b-4f84-9da4-232b87c4b5e9",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data",
          "solution": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLPlayground/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAc
counts/sqlplaygrounddiag645"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLPlayground/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAc
counts/sqlplaygrounddiag645/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/31e91f1c-3e12-2414-2f7b-17c20bc10613",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "31e91f1c-3e12-2414-2f7b-17c20bc10613"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Storage/storageAccounts",
        "impactedValue": "sqlsamplebackup",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T20:32:26.418573Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "42dbf883-9e4b-4f84-9da4-232b87c4b5e9",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data",
          "solution": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLPlayground/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAc
counts/sqlsamplebackup"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/SQLPlayground/providers/Microsoft.Storage/storageAc
counts/sqlsamplebackup/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/089d40f2-8564-d692-0c05-3ed31fd3fc47",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "089d40f2-8564-d692-0c05-3ed31fd3fc47"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Storage/storageAccounts",
        "impactedValue": "cs410033fffa00b7835",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T20:32:26.418573Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "42dbf883-9e4b-4f84-9da4-232b87c4b5e9",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data",
          "solution": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/cloud-shell-storage-westus/providers/Microsoft.Stor
age/storageAccounts/cs410033fffa00b7835"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/cloud-shell-storage-westus/providers/Microsoft.Stor
age/storageAccounts/cs410033fffa00b7835/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/2fb86c1e-d9f5-92dd-45b3-91054ac2545
0",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "2fb86c1e-d9f5-92dd-45b3-91054ac25450"
    },
    {
      "properties": {
        "category": "HighAvailability",
        "impact": "Medium",
        "impactedField": "Microsoft.Storage/storageAccounts",
        "impactedValue": "cs4ee3cb3c03415x43eex8e6",
        "lastUpdated": "2024-04-29T20:32:26.418573Z",
        "recommendationTypeId": "42dbf883-9e4b-4f84-9da4-232b87c4b5e9",
        "shortDescription": {
          "problem": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data",
          "solution": "Enable Soft Delete to protect your blob data"
        },
        "extendedProperties": {
          "recommendationControl": "BusinessContinuity",
          "maturityLevel": "GA"
        },
        "resourceMetadata": {
          "resourceId":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/cloud-shell-storage-westus/providers/Microsoft.Stor
age/storageAccounts/cs4ee3cb3c03415x43eex8e6"
        }
      },
      "id":
"/subscriptions/ee3cb3c0-3415-43ee-8e63-a0170716ee9e/resourceGroups/cloud-shell-storage-westus/providers/Microsoft.Stor
age/storageAccounts/cs4ee3cb3c03415x43eex8e6/providers/Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations/41f06d89-6d86-2e07-8b52-38d882
5e1c0c",
      "type": "Microsoft.Advisor/recommendations",
      "name": "41f06d89-6d86-2e07-8b52-38d8825e1c0c"
    }
  ]
}

DEBUG: ResponseCreated:
DEBUG: BeforeResponseDispatch:

DEBUG: Finally:
DEBUG: CmdletAfterAPICall:
DEBUG: [CmdletProcessRecordAsyncEnd]: Finish HTTP process
DEBUG: CmdletProcessRecordAsyncEnd:
DEBUG: CmdletProcessRecordEnd:
DEBUG: 2:16:00 PM - [ConfigManager] Got nothing from [EnableDataCollection], Module = [], Cmdlet = []. Returning
default value [True].
DEBUG: AzureQoSEvent:  Module: Az.Advisor:2.0.0; CommandName: Get-AzAdvisorRecommendation; PSVersion: 5.1.22621.2506;
IsSuccess: True; Duration: 00:00:01.0499608

Environment data

PS C:\Users\denny> $PSVersionTable

Name                           Value
----                           -----
PSVersion                      5.1.22621.2506
PSEdition                      Desktop
PSCompatibleVersions           {1.0, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0...}
BuildVersion                   10.0.22621.2506
CLRVersion                     4.0.30319.42000
WSManStackVersion              3.0
PSRemotingProtocolVersion      2.3
SerializationVersion           1.1.0.1

Module versions

PS C:\Users\denny> Get-Module Az*

ModuleType Version    Name                                ExportedCommands
---------- -------    ----                                ----------------
Script     2.13.1     Az.Accounts                         {Add-AzEnvironment, Clear-AzConfig, Clear-AzContext, Clear...
Script     2.0.0      Az.Advisor                          {Disable-AzAdvisorRecommendation, Enable-AzAdvisorRecommen...


PS C:\Users\denny>

Error output

PS C:\Users\denny> Resolve-AzError
DEBUG: 2:17:08 PM - ResolveError begin processing with ParameterSet 'AnyErrorParameterSet'.
DEBUG: 2:17:08 PM - using account id '[email protected]'...
DEBUG: 2:17:08 PM - [ConfigManager] Got nothing from [DisplayBreakingChangeWarning], Module = [], Cmdlet = [].
Returning default value [True].


DEBUG: 2:17:08 PM - [ConfigManager] Got nothing from [DisplayRegionIdentified], Module = [], Cmdlet = []. Returning
default value [True].
DEBUG: 2:17:08 PM - [ConfigManager] Got nothing from [CheckForUpgrade], Module = [], Cmdlet = []. Returning default
value [False].
DEBUG: AzureQoSEvent:  Module: Az.Accounts:2.13.1; CommandName: Resolve-AzError; PSVersion: 5.1.22621.2506; IsSuccess:
True; Duration: 00:00:00.0183397
DEBUG: 2:17:08 PM - [ConfigManager] Got nothing from [EnableDataCollection], Module = [], Cmdlet = []. Returning
default value [True].
DEBUG: 2:17:08 PM - ResolveError end processing.

mrdenny avatar Apr 29 '24 21:04 mrdenny

@mrdenny Thank you for your report, we will follow up this issue with the advisor team.

Alex-wdy avatar Apr 30 '24 00:04 Alex-wdy

@mojayara @jportugal0 Can you take a look at this issue?

Alex-wdy avatar May 11 '24 07:05 Alex-wdy

@Alex-wdy could you please share how it was before? where it used to have a bunch of recommendations in the ExtendedProperties value.

I believe ExtendedProperties is working as excepted in the response shared above. It is an object that contains more info about the recommendation, and the fields/ details in this object vary from recommendation to recommendation.

pkrishnanms avatar Jul 16 '24 20:07 pkrishnanms

@mrdenny Can you provide feedback on what you saw on your side ?

Alex-wdy avatar Jul 17 '24 04:07 Alex-wdy

If you pull down the list of Azure recommendations $a = Get-AzAdvisorRecommendation Then pull the extended Metadata Properties (or the Extended Properties) $a[0].ExposedMetadataProperty

All you get back is an empty recordset.

Keys Values Count AdditionalProperties

{} {} 0 {}

Several months ago this would bring back values. If I look in the portal and find the same advisor recommendation there's data there, but there isn't when returning the data from powershell, and I'm not seeing a way to tell the cmdlet to return these values.

mrdenny avatar Jul 17 '24 16:07 mrdenny

Debugging the issue. $a = Get-AzAdvisorRecommendation when I do $a[0].ToJsonstring() -> this shows all the data in the response when converted to json string. and I can also see that $a[0] has properties named -ExposedMetadataProperty, ExtendedProperty, etc but when I do $a[0].ExtendedProperty its empty

pkrishnanms avatar Jul 17 '24 22:07 pkrishnanms